TAXI TUSSLE: Uber Threatened With Legal Action Over Safety Of Self-Driving Cars In California

Published on

Company said earlier they wouldn’t sign up to state regulations about autonomous cars ‘as a matter of principle’ because they have back-up drivers

UBER has been threatened with legal action after it vowed to keep its self-driving cars on the road despite concerns over its safety.

Earlier this week footage emerged showing one of the company’s cars drive through a red light just as a pedestrian was about to cross.

Uber self-driving car

AP:Associated Press
Uber has been threatened with legal action if it keeps its self-driving cars on the road


Video appears to show self-driving Uber car running a red light in San Francisco


YouTube : Charles Rotter
A fellow motorist spotted the vehicle, clearly marked with Uber's logo

Now local authorities in San Francisco, California, have threatened to haul them up before a judge if the service is not suspended immediately.

In a sharply worded letter, attorneys with the California's Department of Justice demanded that Uber get a special state permit if it wants to continue.

If not, “the attorney general will seek injunctive and other appropriate relief”, according to the letter.

Though there was no deadline in the letter, a spokeswoman for California transportation regulators, Melissa Figueroa, told The Associated Press in a text that the state would take action "early next week" if Uber doesn't comply.

Uber began the pilot project Wednesday with a few Volvo SUVs that are kitted out with a suite of sensors allowing them to steer, brake and accelerate.

A person sits behind the wheel, just in case. Officials with Uber and the state have talked several times this week after the state Department of Motor Vehicles issued a similar legal threat.


YouTube : Charles Rotter
The car drove over the pedestrian crossing just as someone stepped out

The leader of the company's self-driving program, Anthony Levandowski, described those as "frank conversations" which left him unswayed .

State lawyers insist that Uber's cars are "autonomous vehicles" which need the permit to ply public roads.

Levandowski said he respectfully disagrees, arguing Uber does not require the permit that 20 other companies testing the technology in California have gotten because the Volvos have backup drivers behind the wheel monitoring the cars.

That means the Volvos are not "autonomous vehicles" under the state's definition, he argued.

Levandowski likened the Volvos' abilities to those of Tesla cars that have the Autopilot feature which allows them to steer without a person touching the wheel and to brake and accelerate without a person touching the pedals.

He questioned why the thousands of Teslas on California roads don't need a permit if Uber's cars do. San Francisco's mayor has sided with the state.


YouTube : Charles Rotter
The incident happened on the launch day of self-driving Ubers in San Francisco

And a consumer advocacy group suggested that the state should do more than force Uber to stop.

"We believe their activity is a criminal offense under the motor vehicle code, punishable with up to six months in jail," John Simpson of the group Consumer Watchdog said in a written statement. "CEO Travis Kalanick should be arrested immediately."

But in a sign of the level of interest in the technology, the mayor of Beverly Hills on Friday voiced his support for Uber testing without the state permit.

The Guardian reports that Levandowski said not complying with state regulations was “an important issue of principle”.

He said: “We cannot in good conscience sign up to regulation for something we’re not doing.”

He added: “It’s an important issue of principle about when companies can operate self-driving cars on the roads and the uneven application of statewide rules across very similar types of technology.”

He continued: “You don’t need a belt and suspenders … if you’re wearing a dress.”

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases