L.A. County Files Criminal Charges Over Porter Ranch Gas Leak

Published on

Prosecutor accuses Southern California Gas Co. of failing to quickly report release of noxious fumes

Southern California Gas Co. on Tuesday was charged with failing to immediately notify state authorities about the natural gas leak in Aliso Canyon.

L.A. County Dist. Atty. Jackie Lacey filed four misdemeanor criminal charges against the company, accusing it of releasing air contaminants and neglecting to report the release of hazardous materials until three days after the leak began Oct. 23.

"We will do everything we can as prosecutors to help ensure that the Aliso Canyon facility is brought into compliance. I believe we can best serve our community using the sanctions available through a criminal conviction to prevent similar public health threats in the future," Lacey said in a statement.

The charges could result in a maximum fine of $25,000 for each day the leak went unreported, and $1,000 for each day the well has polluted the air.

An arraignment is scheduled for Feb. 17 in Santa Clarita.

"We have just been notified of this filing and we are still reviewing it," said Kristine Lloyd, a spokeswoman for the utility.

"We have been working with regulatory agencies to mitigate the odors associated with the natural gas leak and to abate the gas leak as quickly as safety allows. We will defend ourselves vigorously through the judicial process."

The leaking well has released about 80,000 metric tons of methane, and the amount continues to grow. Noxious fumes have driven residents out of more than 5,000 homes in nearby Porter Ranch and surrounding communities, the utility has said.

Residents have complained of headaches, nosebleeds and nausea, which are short-term symptoms associated with the smell in the methane.

One family said Tuesday that it had filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Southern California Gas Co. and its parent company, Sempra Energy, alleging the leak hastened the death of Zelda Rothman.

The 79-year-old, who suffered from lung cancer, died Jan. 25.

According to court papers, Rothman began having intense headaches and migraines in October. She also experienced labored breathing and ultimately required the use of an oxygen tank 24 hours a day.

"Southern California Gas Co.'s decision to operate its inherently dangerous gas storage operation next to 30,000 residents of Porter Ranch without taking all reasonable steps necessary to prevent catastrophic gas leaks is unconscionable," said Scott Glovsky, an attorney for the family.

A representative for the gas company was not available to comment on the lawsuit.

The criminal charges came hours after state Atty. Gen. Kamala Harris joined those suing the gas company, saying the litigation was necessary to hold the utility accountable.

The attorney general's action amends a civil suit filed in December by Los Angeles city and county officials in Superior Court.

The revised joint complaint accuses the gas company of violating health and safety codes, public nuisance laws and hazardous materials reporting requirements, as well as engaging in unfair business practices. The suit seeks civil penalties, restitution and injunctions to enforce regulations.

Harris' joining in the litigation brings to 11 the number of local, state and federal agencies now either investigating or suing the gas company.

Her office is the only one that can press some claims, such as alleging statewide harm through greenhouse gas emissions.

"Quite frankly, it's not litigation overkill at all," said Los Angeles City Councilman Mitchell Englander, who represents communities affected by the leak. "The damage the gas has caused to residents, the environment, the economy, is unprecedented."

Though the amount of gas escaping from the company's Aliso Canyon underground storage field has fallen since peaking in late November, the utility does not expect to be able to attempt to stop the leak until late this month.

The lawsuit includes yet-unnamed corporate officers of the gas company who were in a position of responsibility to either prevent, or immediately correct, the leak.

San Diego-based Sempra Energy's board of directors includes Kathleen Brown, the sister of Gov. Jerry Brown.

In a news release, the attorney general's office said it was best suited to coordinate multiple agency claims while seeking to force the gas company to address the environmental effects of such a large release of methane. The gas has a short life span in the atmosphere but has a powerful greenhouse effect in trapping the Earth's heat radiation.

"Against the backdrop of California's ongoing efforts to reduce [greenhouse gas] emissions generally, this leak is a monumental environmental disaster," the lawsuit contends.

Harris' office stated the attorney general "is already serving a crucial coordinating role" with state, federal and local agencies.

Agency staff said that effort included mapping out what potential enforcement actions those agencies can take against the gas company.

The degree of behind-the-scenes coordination and the lack of public involvement in the leak investigation disturb some consumer advocates.

"This is a coup of government agencies working in secrecy, to figure out how they don't step on each other's toes," said Jamie Court, president of Consumer Watchdog, a California nonprofit organization frequently involved in insurance and utility regulation.

"The public needs to be part of this process. There are too many political alliances and allegiances here."

[email protected]
Twitter: @paigestjohn
[email protected]
Twitter: @TheCityMaven
Times staff writer Sarah D. Wire in Washington contributed to this report.

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases