Google blows deadline for Los Angeles email switch; can¿t meet LAPD needs

Published on

Google has blown the deadline to move the City of Los Angeles
email system and other applications to the Internet Giant’s highly
touted cloud computing system because it hasn’t been able to meet the
security requirements of Los Angeles Police Department.

“Google comes in with this sweetheart deal that was supposed to be
state of the art — supposed to make wonders — and obviously they haven’t
performed,” Councilman Dennis Zine said in a committee meeting last week.

Besides failing to meet security concerns, an LAPD report to City Council says,
the new system has performance issues.  Fifty police department
employees are testing the Google system and report they “consistently
experienced delays in receiving email, up to several hours.”  The
department also needs to know whether particular emails have been
delivered, opened/read and deleted, which the system can’t do. Nor does
the new  system distinguish between a CC or BCC email recipient. In
other words the Google solution can’t do what the old one could and what
the police department needs.

About 6,000 City employees and 13,000 LAPD users remain on the old system.

That means  somebody will have to pay as much as  $414,000 for the
rest of the year for software licenses to continue to use the old
system, according to a report from the City Administrative officer. That’s money the financially strapped city simply doesn’t have.

According to David Sarno in the Los Angeles Times, Google has said it will to cover the licenses for the old system through the end of October.

You’d think all this would give Google pause, but instead its  flacks
in are calling this a mere bump in the road and cite Los Angeles as a
reason all governments should move to the Google cloud.  Instead of
contrition as the news broke over the weekend, Google forged ahead
full-speed Monday with the announcement that GSA has given its new
Government Cloud  Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA)

I don’t know what that implies about the Feds.

As far as the folks at the Googleplex are concerned, every government
large or small should be rushing to sign up.  Those computer engineers
sure have a lot of chutzpa, don’t they?

Instead of fixing what’s not working and figuring out how to meet the
promises to Los Angeles that they failed to deliver before moving
ahead, they are actually trying to sign up more government customers.

I think much of the problem stems from the Google geeks’ mindset. You
throw a product out there in “Beta mode” and tinker with it until you
finally get it right.  That may work if you have something like the
original Gmail, which was aimed at individuals and stayed in “Beta” for 
years. When you’re talking about systems for police departments with
life and death issues sometimes at stake, such a cavalier attitude is
almost criminal.

Consumer Watchdog
Consumer Watchdog
Providing an effective voice for American consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Non-partisan.

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases