Consumer Group Forces Hearing on Allstate’s Excessive Auto Insurance Rates

Published on

Petition Calls for Rate Reduction of at Least $100 to $150 million

Based upon a petition filed by the Proposition 103 Enforcement Project, a consumer watchdog organization, California Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush has granted a hearing to require Allstate to lower its auto insurance rates at least 10% to 15%. The Project’s petition provided strong evidence to the Insurance Commissioner that shows Allstate is overcharging its policyholders at least $100 to $150 million.

“Commissioner Quackenbush couldn’t ignore the overwhelming evidence we provided that shows Allstate‘s rates are excessive,” said Lillian Salinger, staff attorney for the Project.

Under Proposition 103, the 1988 voter-approved initiative, Commissioner Quackenbush is required to stop insurance companies from charging motorists excessive rates. Proposition 103 requires the Commissioner to not approve or allow to remain in effect any rate which is “excessive.”

In June of this year, the Department of Insurance approved a 5.1% rate decrease for Allstate. However, the Project presented the Commissioner with compelling evidence from a well respected insurance expert to show that Allstate‘s rates are still 10% to 15% too high. Based upon this evidence, the Commissioner was compelled to grant the hearing on Allstate‘s excessive rates.

The following is just some of the overwhelming evidence which supports the Project’s petition and will be presented at the hearing:

  • Allstate‘s own internal analysis showed that rates should drop by 9.1%. Yet, Allstate requested only a 5.1% rate decrease. Under Allstate‘s own analysis, the Commissioner approved rates that were excessive by about 4% — or $39 million.

  • Allstate‘s rate analysis does not reflect the shrinking size of claims payouts over the past few years in California. Had Allstate used a more accurate number to reflect this decrease, its rate analysis would have shown that rates should have been reduced by at least 15% — a $150 million savings to policyholders.


Consumer Watchdog
Consumer Watchdog
Providing an effective voice for American consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Non-partisan.

Latest Videos

Latest Articles

In The News

Latest Report

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More articles