Calif. Officials Seek Control Over Insurance Premiums

Published on

Click here to listen to the audio clip of this broadcast.

Blue Shield of California has shocked its policyholders with a proposal to raise premiums by as much as 59 percent, effective March 1. The San Francisco-based company says the higher rates are needed to cover fast-rising costs. It's the second time in less than a year that a California health insurer has asked for a whopping increase. Last year, Anthem Blue Cross drew sharp criticism from the Obama administration after requesting a 39 percent rate hike. Anthem Blue Cross ultimately settled for a 20-percent hike.


Department of Health and Human Services secretary, Kathleen Sebelius says the federal health care law, once it's fully in place, would protect consumers from what some Californians are facing right now. Blue Shield of California has told about 200,000 individual policyholders that their rates will go up on March 1st as much as 59 percent. As a result, some California officials now want control over health care premiums.

NPR's Ina Jaffe reports.

INA JAFFE: Twenty-five-year-old Richard Ruiz works in the movie business. He's an assistant to a film director, but going to the movies, there probably won't be much money left for that after March 1st. Ruiz is a Blue Shield of California customer.

Mr. RICHARD RUIZ (Film Director Assistant): I came back from the holidays and had an envelope from Blue Shield in my mailbox and opened it up and it was a nice New Year's surprise saying that my rate was going up 57 percent.

JAFFE: And so that brings it from what to what?

Mr. RUIZ: I was paying about $70 a month and it's going up to, like, $110.

JAFFE: Ruiz is young and healthy and has a barebones policy.

Mr. RUIZ: Basically if I get hit by a car or if, you know, something else catastrophic happens.

JAFFE: But his budget is barebones, too. So, an extra 40 bucks a month is a big deal.

Mr. RUIZ: Month to month, when you're basically breaking even and everyone is telling you the best thing you can do as a young person is save and not go into debt and be financially responsible, every little bit matters.

JAFFE: Blue Shield was unable to provide anyone to speak to us by our deadline. In a written statement on their website, they said that the increases were due to rapidly rising medical costs, increased utilization and healthier people dropping coverage because of the bad economy. They emphasized that the rate hikes had little to do with the federal health care law, which the company expected to be helpful over the long haul.

Regardless, California's newly-elected insurance commissioner would like Blue Shield to hold off. In a conference call, Democrat Dave Jones pointed out he was just sworn in this week. And so…

Mr. DAVE JONES (California Insurance Commissioner): I have asked that the company postpone its rate increase 60 days in order to afford me the opportunity to fully review the proposed rate increase.

JAFFE: Though, Jones said that doesn't mean he can do anything about it.

Mr. JONES: Unfortunately, under California law, the insurance commissioner does not have the legal authority to reject excessive premium increases.

JAFFE: This is not the first time that a California health insurer has initiated a huge hike in premiums. Last year, Anthem Blue Cross wanted a 39 percent increase and became a talking point in the Obama administration's push to pass the health care overhaul. The company ultimately settled for an average increase of about 14 percent.

Now some California legislators and consumer advocates want the state to take more control over health insurance. Such legislation has failed in the past, but Jamie Court, the president of Consumer Watchdog, is feeling more hopeful now.

Mr. JAMIE COURT (President, Consumer Watchdog): We now have a new governor. We now have a new legislature and we are now working on legislation this year to do it again. And my consumer group is committed to going to the ballot box to get premium regulation. If the legislature won't give it to us, the voters are going to take matters into their own hands.

JAFFE: That's not an idle threat. About two decades ago, Jamie Court's organization sponsored a successful initiative that gave the state of California control over the premiums for automobile and other kinds of property insurance. Meanwhile, Blue Shield says that even with the upcoming rate hikes, the company expects to lose tens of millions of dollars providing individual policies.

Ina Jaffe, NPR News.

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases