NHTSA Must Quickly Enact Enforceable Safety Standards for Robot Cars or States Must Move If Feds Fail to Do Their Job, Consumer Watchdog Tells “Automated Vehicles Symposium 2017”

Published on

SAN FRANCISCO, CA — Consumer Watchdog today called on the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration to promptly adopt enforceable federal safety standards covering self-driving autonomous vehicles and warned that if the federal efforts stall, states must act immediately to fill the void and protect consumer safety.

“No federal or state standards would leave us at the mercy of manufacturers as they rush to use our public highways as their private laboratories however they wish with no safety protections at all,” said John M. Simpson, Consumer Watchdog Privacy project director. He was speaking at Automated Vehicles Symposium 2017 in San Francisco.

California’s initial autonomous vehicle testing regulations are working, Simpson said, noting that 36 companies have obtained permits to test robot cars on our roads. Crash reports and disengagement reports must be filed, so the public knows what’s happening around them, he noted.

Last month Consumer Watchdog issued a report warning that robot cars operating without mandatory safety, security, privacy and ethical standards will pose unprecedented risks to the American public. Read the report, Self-Driving Vehicles: The Threat to Consumers, here: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/resources/self_driving_consumer_threat_report.pdf

In September during the Obama Administration NHTSA issued its automated vehicle policy, which relies on a 15-point voluntary safety assessment. Last month Secretary of Transportation Elaine Chao said her department was reviewing that policy and would issue its revised policy guidelines within a few months. No voluntary safety assessments have been filed.

Instead of offering meaningful safety protections, Simpson said, federal efforts appear to be aimed at thwarting those who might act.

For example, Simpson said, the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Digital Commerce and Consumer Protection held a hearing in June on proposed legislation that would prevent states from enacting autonomous vehicle safety standards even though no federal regulations exist.

The proposed House legislation to pre-empt state safety regulations “would leave a regulatory void without meaningful safety protections,” Simpson told the Symposium. He echoed Consumer Watchdog’s written testimony to the subcommittee.

Both at the Symposium and in subcommittee testimony Simpson stressed that regulations covering jurisdiction over licensing; enacting and enforcing traffic laws and regulations; and regulating vehicle insurance and liability must remain with the states.

“Lost in the hyperbole over robot cars is a realistic assessment of the likely costs to both consumers and taxpayers particularly over the coming decades, when robot cars and human drivers will share a ‘hybrid highway,’” said Simpson.

Simpson also reiterated Consumer Watchdog’s call for Congress to increase funding for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration so it has the resources necessary to enact safety performance standards and regulate self-driving robot cars.

Simpson noted that if the federal government does enact Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FVMSS) covering autonomous vehicles, they will under current law pre-empt state safety regulations.

“There will be no dreaded ‘patch-work’ of competing and possibly contradictory regulations that some fret and warn about,” said Simpson. “NHTSA just needs to do its job and protect the public’s safety.”

Consumer Watchdog’s written testimony to the subcommittee concluded:

“We call on you to require the development of enforceable federal safety performance standards. Responsible regulation goes hand-in-hand with innovation. Voluntary ‘standards’ in the auto industry have repeatedly been proven to be weak and insufficient. Safety must come before the automakers’ bottom lines. Consumer Watchdog calls on you to require NHTSA to enact the necessary regulations to protect the safety of our highways and give the agency the necessary resources to do so.”

The next few years will feature complex interactions between people, computers, cars and public streets and freeways, Simpson told the Symposium. He cited six principles that Consumer Watchdog believes must be adopted to deal with the challenge posed by autonomous vehicle technology. They are:

1. Protect the civil justice system. The state-based civil justice system – open courts, impartial judges and citizen juries – is fully equipped to handle the determination of legal responsibility as our transportation system evolves over the coming decades. Disputes over who is at fault in a crash involving a self-driving car or truck will require the full power of civil justice system, with its procedural safeguards of an impartial judge, full public transparency, and trial by citizen juries, to investigate and publicly expose the cause of crashes, compensate the victims for deaths, injuries and property damage, punish the wrongdoer, and force manufacturers to make changes in their products to prevent future harm. When their autonomous technologies fail, hardware and software manufacturers must be held strictly liable. Lawmakers should reject legislation to limit or restrict state consumer protection laws. Manufacturers must not be permitted to evade these consumer protections by inserting arbitration clauses, “hold harmless” provisions or other waivers in their contracts.

2. Enact stronger state consumer protections against insurance company abuses. According to a 2013 report by the Consumer Federation of America, “California stands out from all other states in having the best insurance regulatory system for protecting consumers.” Enacted by California voters in 1988, California’s insurance reform law provides precisely the stronger protections consumers will require in the era of robot vehicles. The reforms, known as Proposition 103, have protected motorists (along with homeowners, renters, businesses and medical providers) against unjust insurance rates (including product liability insurance rates) and anti-consumer and discriminatory practices. The law’s emphasis on rewarding drivers with lower insurance premiums based on their safety record, their annual mileage, their driving experience, and other rating factors within their control that are “substantially related to the risk of loss,” will be critical in the new automotive era. Proposition 103’s mandate for public disclosure and public participation in regulatory matters are essential components of a system that will be trusted by consumers.

3. Enact auto safety standards. Private companies cannot be trusted to develop and deploy robot cars and trucks without rules. The federal auto safety agency or other relevant federal agencies, or in their absence, state auto safety agencies, must develop standards for the testing and deployment of the multiple technologies required by robot vehicles. These standards must address safety, security, privacy and the software that determines the robot’s actions in the event of an impending collision and as it makes life and death decisions. They must be enforceable by consumers in courts of law.

4. Stronger laws are needed to protect consumers’ privacy. The laws have not kept pace with the evolution of technology and the collection and monetization of consumers’ personal data. Hardware and software manufacturers and insurance companies must be barred from utilizing tracking, sensor or communications data, or transferring it to third parties for commercial gain, absent separate written consent (which should not be required as a condition of accessing the services of the vehicle/manufacturer, and which should be revocable by the consumer at any time).

5. Bar federal interference in state consumer protection laws. Neither Congress nor federal agencies should be permitted to preempt or override stronger state based civil justice, insurance reform or auto safety laws.

6. Respect democratic and human values. The sponsors of self-driving vehicles have promoted the myth that machines are infallible in order to justify the wholesale departure from a panoply of norms that form founding principles for the nation, beginning with the rule of law; individual and corporate responsibility; long held legal principles that distinguish between human beings and property; and the transparency of public officials and institutions that is a hallmark of democracy. The strategy of substituting robot values for human values has reached its apotheosis in the determination by robot car company executives to program computers to make life and death decisions, and to keep that decision-making process secret. Lawmakers will need to impose the rule of law and other attributes of American democracy upon the executives of the hardware and software companies that manufacture self-driving cars.

Read Consumer Watchdog’s written subcommittee testimony here: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/househavstatement062717.pdf

View the archived video of the subcommittee hearing here: https://energycommerce.house.gov/hearings-and-votes/hearings/self-driving-vehicle-legislation

The statement to the House Subcommittee came after Consumer Watchdog’s in-depth study, “Self-Driving Vehicles: The Threat to Consumers.” Read the report here: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/resources/self_driving_consumer_threat_report.pdf

-30-

Visit our website at http://www.consumerwatchdog.org

John M. Simpson
John M. Simpson
John M. Simpson is an American consumer rights advocate and former journalist. Since 2005, he has worked for Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan nonprofit public interest group, as the lead researcher on Inside Google, the group's effort to educate the public about Google's dominance over the internet and the need for greater online privacy.

Latest Privacy Videos

Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Wall Street using AI
01:48
Video thumbnail
KCBA (FOX) CA: Clearview AI Is Creating An AI Facial Recognition Software That Violates Privacy Laws
00:35
Video thumbnail
KGO CA: Consumer Watchdog Calls Attorney General to Investigate Clearview AI For Violating State Law
03:06
Video thumbnail
KNTV-SF (NBC) - San Francisco, CA: Tesla Recalls Millions of Cars
02:29
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Clearview AI
01:19
Video thumbnail
Californians Now Have More Power Over Their Data
01:07
Video thumbnail
KPIX CBS TV-5 San Francisco, CA: Your Car's Computer Could Be Tracking And Reporting Your Every Move
00:48
Video thumbnail
California Votes YES on Privacy- Prop 24
13:14
Video thumbnail
Rage For Justice Report Podcast- Prop 24 For Your Privacy
19:18
Video thumbnail
Consumer Watchdog Hacks Tesla
02:00
Video thumbnail
FOX KSWB: New Internet-Connected Cars Could Get Hacked
01:05
Video thumbnail
ABC: Kill Switch Report Highlights Widespread Hacking Vulnerability of Connected Cars
02:12
Video thumbnail
KTTV FOX: Consumer Watchdog Report Warns That Hackers Can Take Over Your Car
05:02
Video thumbnail
SPECNEWS1: Watchdog Warns Cars With Internet Connection Vulnerable to Hacking
00:37
Video thumbnail
KBCW: Connected Cars Pose Risk to Driver Safety Due to Hacking Vulnerability
02:31
Video thumbnail
ABC KGO: Whistleblower Engineers Warn Connected Cars Need A Kill Switch to Stop Hacking
02:10
Video thumbnail
KCAL: Alarming Watchdog Report Shows Connected Cars Are Vulnerable to Hacking
02:51
Video thumbnail
ABC KGTV: Report Says Internet-Linked Cars Are Vulnerable To Hackers
00:30
Video thumbnail
KTTV Fox 11: Consumer Watchdog Report Shows How Vulnerable Connected Cars Are To Dangerous Hacking
01:05
Video thumbnail
NBC: Watchdog Report Show Connected Cars Lack of Cybersecurity Put Drivers at Risk
03:38
Video thumbnail
CBS KGPE: Connected Cars Pose A Cybersecurity Risk
03:05
Video thumbnail
Fox WDAF: High-Tech Cars Put Drivers At Risk Of Hacking Interference
00:47
Video thumbnail
ABC WXYZ: Connected Cars Can Be Hacked Says Kill Switch Report
01:36
Video thumbnail
KTTV GDLA: US Senators Write NHTSA About Connected Car Concerns
01:17
Video thumbnail
FOX KPTV: Kill Switch Report Details Cybersecurity Issues With Internet Connected Cars
02:28
Video thumbnail
CBS LA: Kill Switch Study Finds Connected Cars Are Vulnerable to Hacking
01:41
Video thumbnail
FOX KTTV: Consumer Watchdog on Privacy Issues, Hacking Risks With Internet-Connected Toys
03:00
Video thumbnail
CBS Evening News With Norah O'Donnell: Jamie Court Explains the Value of CA's Consumer Privacy Act
02:04
Video thumbnail
WAFF TV-48 Alabama: Watchdog Report Highlights Car-Hacking Risks
03:16
Video thumbnail
ABC KFSN: Internet-Connected Vehicles At Risk Of Being Hacked Says New Watchdog Report
00:33
Video thumbnail
KPIX CBS: Connected Cars Need A Kill Switch To Stop Dangerous Hacking
02:31
Video thumbnail
KCAL: Kill Switch Report Warns of Hacking Risk For Connected Cars
01:29
Video thumbnail
KTLA: Consumer Watchdog Report Warns of Hacking Risk For Internet Connected Cars
01:05
Video thumbnail
CBS This Morning: "Movie Pass Engages in Deceptive Data Mining" Says Consumer Watchdog
03:09
Video thumbnail
California Passes Strictest Privacy Law in Nation - Rising Up w/Sonali
13:09
Video thumbnail
Consumer Watchdog Exposes
04:20
Video thumbnail
How Google backs Backpage Sex-Trafficking, Press Conference Pt. 1
14:55
Video thumbnail
How Google backs Backpage Sex-Trafficking, Press Conference Pt. 3
14:57
Video thumbnail
Amazon Prime? Or Amazon Slime?
01:22
Video thumbnail
KMAX CBS Sacramento: Amazon shows deceptive prices to trick consumers, says Consumer Watchdog
00:31
Video thumbnail
KABC Los Angeles: Anti-Child Sex Trafficking Groups Call Out Google's Backing of Backpage
02:11
Video thumbnail
KPIX-CBS, San Francisco: DMV Investigates Uber After Consumer Watchdog report
00:28
Video thumbnail
KFMB CBS 8, San Diego: Amazon Prime Day Deals? Consumer Watchdog Says Beware
01:58
Video thumbnail
Asking about I AM JANE DOE at Google Shareholder Meeting
03:33
Video thumbnail
KNBC Los Angeles: Liza Tucker weighs in on regulators' failure to test camp for toxic waste
06:42
Video thumbnail
KNBC Los Angeles: Consumer Watchdog shows how Google helped fund defense of Backpage
01:58
Video thumbnail
KIRO CBS 7, Seattle, WA: Consumer Watchdog: Amazon Uses Fake "List Prices" to Trick Consumers
00:44
Video thumbnail
"I Am Jane Doe" introduction
01:42
Video thumbnail
WZZM ABC, Grand Rapids, MI: New Bill Would Put Driverless Cars In Legal Limbo Says Consumer Watchdog
00:34

Latest Privacy Releases

Privacy In The News

Latest Privacy Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Privacy Releases