Medical Negligence Caps Target Women

Published on

WOMEN are disproportionately harmed by outdated limits on the ability of injured patients to recover damages. California’s cap on compensation for “non-economic” or quality of life harm prevents women from getting justice.

Medical injuries unique to women have long been undervalued. By virtue of being the sex that bears children, that remains outside the wage-earning work force or works fewer hours for less money when they raise them, and other results of women’s reproductive character, MICRA has a disproportionate impact on women who have been the victims of medical negligence. 

Women and caps

Much as the glass ceiling continues to undercut the incomes of working women, the malpractice cap on non-economic damages means compensation for those harmed by medical errors is largely determined by the income of the person who was injured. With working women still earning only 80% of what men earn, compensation for womens’ lost future income is less for the exact same injuries. 

A stay-at-home parent or a parent who works only part-time outside the home is treated very differently under caps than someone who is working full-time at a high-paying job. The work of homemakers has no value under MICRA, and so no wage loss is awarded in the case of their deaths. 

Women also suffer specific injuries that men do not and are more likely to suffer harm compensated only by “non-economic” or quality of life damage awards. These include sexual or reproductive harm, pregnancy loss, unnecessary mastectomy, and harm from sexual assault by doctors. The injuries they sustain, from impaired fertility to miscarriage, incontinence, scarring or disfigurement in intimate parts of the body, also have no “economic” value. These women are unlikely to have lost income, yet they have clearly suffered grievous injury. Such damage is considered “non-economic” and California’s cap limits compensation for these losses to an amount below what anyone would consider fair in 2020, regardless of the severity of the harm.

A study by Lucinda Finley of SUNY Buffalo Law, “The Hidden Victims of Tort Reform: Women, Children and the Elderly,” explains well how caps disproportionately impact women:

 

…certain injuries that happen primarily to women are compensated predominantly or almost exclusively through noneconomic loss damages. These injuries include sexual or reproductive harm, pregnancy loss, and sexual assault injuries. The impact of these injuries—impaired fertility or sexual functioning, miscarriage, incontinence, trauma associated with sexual relationships, and scarring or disfigurement in sensitive, intimate areas of the body—is not primarily on the economic wage earning aspects of life. Rather, the impact is more in terms of emotional suffering and self-esteem—an impaired sense of self and ability to function as a whole person, or damaged relationships. These priceless aspects of life hold little economic worth in the market, so market-referenced economic loss damages are ill-suited and inadequate to compensate for them.

…Consequently, any cap on noneconomic loss damages will deprive women of a much greater proportion and amount of a jury award than men. Noneconomic loss damage caps therefore amount to a form of discrimination against women and contribute to unequal access to justice or fair compensation for women.”

 

 

Latest Patient Safety Videos

Video thumbnail
Carmen Balber testifies at Sunset Review about Medical Board Reforms
02:03
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges Before
02:16
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt Testifies Calling for Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges before
01:49
Video thumbnail
Maria Ibarra Navarrette Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
00:34
Video thumbnail
Patricia Plascencia Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:04
Video thumbnail
Evelen Martinez Testifies Calling for Death Complaints Must be Investigated before
02:11
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt-Ramos testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges before
02:48
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges Before
01:57
Video thumbnail
Jan Kamel testifies at MBC Meeting 2 9 23
00:34
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt-Ramos Testifies in Support of Bringing Medical Board Meetings to Central Valley
02:52
Video thumbnail
Kimberly Turbin Testifies Calling for Serious Bodily Injury Complaints to be Investigated Before
02:11
Video thumbnail
Moises Espinoza Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
01:29
Video thumbnail
Judith Gorcey Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:48
Video thumbnail
Selah O’Connor Testifies Calling for Serious Bodily Complaints Must Be Investigated before
02:39
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:24
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies Calling for Death Complaints Must Be Investigated Before
02:14
Video thumbnail
Monique Himes Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:15
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:10
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
02:25
Video thumbnail
David Gorcey Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
01:14
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley 2/9/23
01:05
Video thumbnail
Maria Ibarra Navarrette Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:04
Video thumbnail
Patty Plascencia Testifies Calling for Serious Bodily Injury Complaints to be Investigated Before
02:31
Video thumbnail
Denise Johnson Testifies Calling for Death Complaints Must Be Investigated Before
02:25
Video thumbnail
Alka Airy Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
03:12
Video thumbnail
Tracey Mueller Gibbs Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
03:20
Video thumbnail
KBAK-TV; Bakersfield Report on EuroPhoria
03:00
Video thumbnail
KGO - San Francisco, CA; The Shortest, Most Expensive Ambulance Ride
05:20
Video thumbnail
23 (ABC); Tracy Dominguez and Selena Alvarez Seek Justice At The Osteopathic Medical Board Meeting
02:43
Video thumbnail
KTLA - Los Angeles, CA; Consumer Watchdog Group Members Calling For A Patient Bill of Rights
02:31
Video thumbnail
KNBC - Los Angeles, CA; Medical Board Member TJ Watkins Calls On Californians To Help
04:17
Video thumbnail
Michele Ramos at Med Board Meeting 12 1 22
03:49
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez at Medical Board Meeting 12 2 22
03:44
Video thumbnail
Xavier de Leon calls in Med Board Meeting 12 2 22
02:24
Video thumbnail
Denise Johnson calls in Med Board Meeting 12 1 22 Captioned Copy 01
02:25
Video thumbnail
Mark Wilson calls in Medical Board Meeting 12 2 22
02:04
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt Ramos at Med Board Meeting 12 2 22 Captioned
03:58
Video thumbnail
Robert Andrian at Medical Board 12 2 22 Captioned
03:47
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt calls in Med Board Meeting 12 1 22 Captioned
01:51
Video thumbnail
Alka Airy calls in Medical Board meetiong 12 2 22
03:19
Video thumbnail
Annette Ramirez calls in to Med Board Meeting 12 2 22
02:49
Video thumbnail
Tammy Smick at Medical Board 12 2 22
03:54
Video thumbnail
Carmen Balber at CA Med Board 12 2 22
03:03
Video thumbnail
Denise Johnson calls in Medical Board Meeting 12 2 22
01:57
Video thumbnail
Kim Turbin at Medical Board 12 2 22 Captioned
02:47
Video thumbnail
Alka Airy calls in Med Board Meeting 12 1 22
03:07
Video thumbnail
Susan Shinazy calls in Med Board Meeting 12 2 22
02:48
Video thumbnail
Robert Andrian calls in Med Board Meeting 12 1 22
02:54
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt calls in Medical Board Meeting 12 2 22
01:39

Latest Patient Safety Releases

Patient Safety In The News

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Patient Safety Releases