By Laurence Darmiento, LOS ANGELES TIMES
Former San Francisco Supervisor Jane Kim overcame her lack of name recognition to win the race to be California’s next insurance commissioner by making a novel proposal: establishing a government-run wildfire program that would radically overhaul the state’s troubled home insurance market.
Her Natural Disaster Insurance for All (opens in new tab) plan promises to make home insurance affordable and increase its availability by taking the profit motive out of the system, eliminating costs such as high executive salaries and, most importantly, having as a core mission the reduction of growing wildfire risks that have caused a series of catastrophic blazes in the last decade.
Those blazes — culminating in the Jan. 7, 2025, firestorms that damaged or destroyed more than 16,000 structures (opens in new tab) in the Pacific Palisades and Altadena areas alone — caused insurers to drop policyholders in fire-prone areas while raising rates, though statewide they remain near the nationwide average depending on the study.
…
The idea for a state-run wildfire plan funded by policyholders is not unique. A similar plan was briefly outlined as an option in a natural catastrophe resilience study (opens in new tab)ordered by Gov. Gavin Newsom this year in response to climate change and the Palisades and Eaton wildfires.
It also would not be the only state-operated insurance program. The California Earthquake Authority (opens in new tab) was established in 1996 following the 1994 Northridge earthquake, when insurers were not willing to offer the coverage.
Still, insurance industry officials, consumer advocates and others say that the incoming commissioner’s plan, never tried before in the U.S., leaves fundamental issues such as startup financing and claims handling yet to be fleshed out, and even Kim acknowledges she sees it as a starting point.
…
Relying on significant reinsurance could lower the needed startup capital to $6 billion, the study found, but given its costs could result in aggregate homeowner insurance premiums rising from $18 billion today to more than $20 billion. Kim says that a public model could eventually reduce wildfire risks to make home insurance more affordable.
Others question that. Carmen Balber, executive director of Los Angeles advocacy group Consumer Watchdog (opens in new tab), said that using reinsurance to significantly capitalize an insurance program can be problematic because it can result in high premiums or high deductibles to keep premiums down. She cited the California Earthquake Authority as an example.
“That has been the No. 1 concern we’ve always had, because we have an example of state disaster insurance: It’s the CEA, and it’s broken,” she said. “The insurance industry has been collecting our premiums for a century, and nationwide has built up $1.2 trillion in surplus in case the worst catastrophe ever strikes. How do we replicate that on a California scale?”
The costs for a CEA policy vary widely depending on a home’s age, construction, location and the policy deductible, which ranges from 5% to 25%. The authority, initially capitalized by participating insurers, has fewer than 1 million policies, largely for homes but also condos, rentals and mobile homes. An annual homeowner premium would typically cost at least $2,000, by one estimate.
…
Click here to read the full article.
Consumer Watchdog · November 15, 2026
https://consumerwatchdog.org/in-the-news/los-angeles-times-the-new-state-insurance-commissioner-has-a-plan-to-overhaul-the-troubled-home-insurance-market-will-it-work/
© 2026 Consumer Watchdog. Printed November 16, 2026.

