Consumer Watchdog

Expose. Confront. Change.

Consumer Watchdog

Law360 – Calif Justices To Weigh USAA Military Rank Bias Row

By Abraham Gross, LAW 360

The California Supreme Court will weigh in on a case alleging USAA unlawfully discriminated against lower-ranking service members by favoring officers, setting the stage for a landmark interpretation of a decades-old insurance proposition.

The justices agreed on Nov. 10 to hear two questions certified by the Ninth Circuit to resolve claims by a class of servicemembers and veterans.

The case, led by former Marine radio operator Eileen-Gayle Coleman and Army veteran Robert Castro, claims that USAA violated the state insurance code by charging lower-ranking good drivers higher rates than officers.

The Ninth Circuit told the justices that in order to determine if USAA breached state laws governing good-driver discounts and if the class could recover, the justices needed to resolve several apparent inconsistencies between a state insurance reform statute known as Proposition 103 and other parts of the state’s insurance code.

Here, Law360 takes a close look at the case.

The Coverage Dispute

Coleman and Castro filed suit in February 2021 alleging that USAA General charged California-based active service members and veterans a higher “good driver” rate than United Services Automobile Association, another USAA affiliate, did for officers.

The good-driver discount, enshrined in Proposition 103, requires that auto insurers provide a discount of at least 20% to policyholders that qualify as “good drivers” under specified criteria.

The class alleges that since both insurers were wholly owned affiliates of USAA, the practice violates California Insurance Code Section 1861.16(b), which obligates insurers to provide good drivers with the best discounted rate across all its affiliates.

That section of the insurance code is intended to close a perceived loophole in Proposition 103 that could have allowed insurers to steer “good drivers” to affiliates with higher rates, according to the Ninth Circuit.

USAA has countered that its rates are approved by the California Department of Insurance and that other factors lead to the different premiums. According to USAA, the plaintiffs are effectively seeking to force the insurer to enroll them with a different affiliate for which they don’t qualify.

“This radical restructuring would send the risk pool of each affiliate into flux and likely would require USAA to overhaul its CDI-approved rates,” the insurer wrote in an April 2021 motion to dismiss.

USAA has also argued that the discrimination claim fails because California’s insurance code provides carveouts to insurance providers for the military. The insurer cites the guarantee in Section 11628(f)(1) that nothing in the code bars an insurer from limiting insurance to persons in “governmental or military service or segments of categories thereof.”

Five years ago, U.S. District Judge Cathy Ann Bencivengo reject the insurers’ motion to dismiss the case, saying they failed to establish they were exempt from 1861.16(b).

The case was then transferred to Judge Robert S. Huie, who agreed with USAA that it was not bound by the rule.

Judge Huie also rejected alternative arguments that Section 11628(f)(1) could not be given effect under California precedent, stating that the legislature could not amend a proposition in any way that did not further its purpose. Instead, he concluded that the code did not alter the proposition because 1861.16(b) was not part of Proposition 103 at all.

The class subsequently appealed to the Ninth Circuit, which asked the California Supreme Court to weigh in on several key issues that it said were unsettled under existing state court precedent.

The Issues

At stake in the California high court’s ruling is whether California law requires military insurers to offer good drivers the best rate across all their affiliates. The court will also be asked to decide if policyholders can challenge rates already approved by the state’s insurance commissioner.

The California justices will consider if 11628(f)(1) creates an exception to 1861.16(b), which would allow USAA to offer different rates to different segments of the military. They will also determine if 11628(f)(1) constitutes an invalid legislative amendment to Proposition 103 because it doesn’t “further the purpose” of the amendment.

The more impactful decision, however, may lie in how the justices resolve the question of whether — and how — state law insulates insurers from recovery actions for approved rates.

According to the Ninth Circuit certification, there is an apparent inconsistency in which insurers, like public utilities, seem to be insulated from recovery actions for approved rates. At the same time, Proposition 103 appears to bind insurance regulations to the same rules as other businesses.

California appeals courts have been divided on whether the filed-rate doctrine applies to the insurance code, according to the Ninth Circuit. And even if it did, it is not clear if the principle would preempt the USAA challenge, which does not challenge the rate itself but rather how it’s applied.

“For all these reasons, we conclude that these complex issues of California insurance law are best resolved by a state authority,” the Ninth Circuit wrote.

Next steps

In the wake of the Ninth Circuit’s certification request, Consumer Watchdogfounder Harvey Rosenfield, who authored Proposition 103 and is serving as co-counsel for the class, said the case gives the state justices an opportunity to restore private enforcement rights for Proposition 103.

“If an insurer discriminates, violates Proposition 103, or engages in another unlawful practice, the fact that money was collected through an approved rate should not place an insurance company above the law,” Rosenfield said in a statement.

A spokesperson for USAA previously told Law360 that it will continue to defend against the suit, adding that the company “provides competitive products and exceptional value to the military community” and that the “allegations in this suit have no merit, which is why it was dismissed at the trial court.”

As of Thursday, there are no hearings yet scheduled for the case.

The case is Coleman et al. v. United Services Automobile Association et al., case number S298496, in the Supreme Court of California.

–Additional reporting by Hope Patti, Daniel Wilson and Alyssa Aquino. Editing by Amy Rowe.

Consumer Watchdog · November 20, 2026
https://consumerwatchdog.org/in-the-news/law360-calif-justices-to-weigh-usaa-military-rank-bias-row/
© 2026 Consumer Watchdog. Printed November 20, 2026.