California Has the Power to Respond to the Insurance Crisis
After years of skyrocketing insurance bills and policy non-renewals by insurance companies, it was good to hear candidates for Governor offer proposals…
May 5, 2026William Pletcher is a nationally recognized consumer advocate who has recently joined Consumer Watchdog as Litigation Director, where he helps lead the organization’s legal battles to hold powerful corporations accountable and protect Californians from unlawful, fraudulent, and unfair business practices and government abuses. He recently received the California Lawyers Association’s Antitrust and Unfair Competition Law Section’s Consumer and Unfair Competition Law Award for 2025 for his leadership in consumer protection statewide, and the National Health Care Anti-Fraud Association’s 2023 Investigation of the Year Award as part of a team that prosecuted nationwide COVID-19 testing fraud.
This past spring, he helped lead the Consumer Watchdog legal team’s successful opposition to State Farm’s emergency rate hike, securing major relief for policyholders by seeing that the emergency request was reduced nearly $400 million in a high-stakes regulatory hearing. He is also directing the organization’s ongoing legal support for those impacted by the January 2025 Los Angeles wildfires, including efforts to help ensure fair payment for smoke and ash damage and to block the FAIR Plan’s unlawful attempt to shift wildfire costs onto consumers. Will also co-authored Consumer Watchdog’s recent amicus brief in federal litigation challenging President Trump’s unconstitutional use of emergency powers to impose tariffs—contributing to district court rulings that blocked the tariffs as unconstitutional. The appeals to these rulings are ongoing.
His past work includes winning a $243 million judgment against a predatory student loan servicer, helping secure a $26 million healthcare fraud settlement over fake COVID-19 testing, and obtaining full restitution and product reformulation in a landmark false advertising case against a vitamin manufacturer for the presence of heavy metals in prenatal supplements. He also helped lead efforts to secure restitution and injunctive relief for victims of fraudulent solar sales schemes targeting low-income homeowners and led a joint enforcement action with the California Attorney General’s Office that hold an online platform accountable for violations of children’s privacy rights under COPPA and the CCPA.
Previously, Will served as a Deputy Attorney General, where he was recognized by then–Attorney General Kamala Harris with Attorney General’s Awards for his trial work and his roles in landmark settlements, including the $15 billion Volkswagen diesel emissions case, a $500 million emissions fraud settlement with Fiat Chrysler, and a $50 million debt collection settlement with Chase Bank.
He earned his J.D. from Stanford Law School, where he was an editor of the Stanford Law & Policy Review, and graduated summa cum laude with honors in the liberal arts from Ohio State University. He clerked for Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit and brings deep experience in complex litigation, public law, and consumer advocacy.
After years of skyrocketing insurance bills and policy non-renewals by insurance companies, it was good to hear candidates for Governor offer proposals…
May 5, 2026Los Angeles, CA – Consumer Watchdog is asking the Office of Administrative Law to reject Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara’s proposed intervenor regulations unless…
Apr 29, 2026Los Angeles, CA – On April 17, 2026, Consumer Watchdog filed its opening trial brief in its lawsuit challenging Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara…
Apr 24, 2026Los Angeles, CA – Ignoring the protests of 32 consumer protection, labor, senior, immigrant, low-income, and public advocacy organizations, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara…
Apr 20, 2026Organization Urges Court to Grant Review of Federal Circuit Decision Allowing Sevenfold Expansion of Section 301 China Tariffs with No Meaningful Limits…
Mar 26, 2026Los Angeles, CA – A broad statewide coalition of 32 consumer protection, labor, senior, immigrant, low-income, and public advocacy organizations urged Insurance…
Mar 12, 2026Consumer Watchdog today announced a filed State Farm settlement that could save California policyholders about $530 million
Mar 6, 2026Decision Affirms Only Congress May Tax Americans; Ends Unlawful “Emergency” Tariffs That Are Driving Up Consumer Prices Los Angeles, CA — In a landmark…
Feb 20, 2026Published Decision Rejects Industry Effort to Close California Courthouse Doors Los Angeles, CA — Consumer Watchdog, working with a broad coalition of consumer…
Jan 22, 2026Washington, DC – Consumer Watchdog today filed an amicus curiae brief in the U.S. Supreme Court urging the Justices to strike down President…
Oct 8, 2025Los Angeles, CA – Consumer Watchdog executed a settlement this week with Stillwater Insurance Company and the California Department of Insurance, resolving the…
Sep 23, 2025Judge Rejects Illinois Insurance Department’s Bid To Argue Against Public Transparency Consumer Watchdog Led Effort To Stop Out-of-State Agency
Sep 10, 2025WASHINGTON, D.C. — The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled today that the Trump administration’s use of emergency powers to…
Aug 29, 2025Consumer Watchdog Praises Ruling Upholding Public Access and Proposition 103 Transparency Los Angeles, CA – An Administrative Law Judge today issued a series of rulings…
Aug 27, 2025Filing in Yeh v. Barrington Pacific, LLC urges the Court of Appeal to reject federal-style standing hurdles that would weaken Californians’ consumer-privacy rights under…
Aug 26, 2025Lawsuit Alleges Improper Denial of Compensation, Hostility Toward Consumer Advocacy Groups, and Biased Process Los Angeles, CA — Consumer Watchdog and the…
Jul 30, 2025Washington, D.C. — Consumer Watchdog filed an amicus curiae brief today in the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, expanding…
Jul 29, 2025Los Angeles, CA – Today, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge adopted a ruling allowing Consumer Watchdog’s lawsuit to move forward against Insurance Commissioner…
Jul 23, 2025