Los Angeles Superior Court No. BC 300142 Consumer Watchdog is representing a former Farmers Group, Inc. customer (“Intervenor”) who is challenging portions of a $455 million settlement of a national class action lawsuit against Farmers. (For the most up-to-date information about this case, see CASE UPDATES to the right.) Any person who was enrolled in a Farmers insurance policy between January 1, 1999 and December 31, 2010 may object to the settlement and/or show up in court on September 7, 2011.

The case, known as Fogel v. Farmers Group, Inc., charges that Farmers required its policyholders to pay too much for a management fee (“attorney in fact fee”)  that Farmers builds into its auto, home, and business insurance premiums. The company earned a 50% profit on the fee. Last October, the plaintiff and defendants announced a settlement of the case, which includes an award of $455 million to consumers and $90 million for the plaintiffs’ attorneys. Consumer Watchdog counsel, on behalf of the Intervenor, opposes the proposed settlement on the following grounds: 1. Consumers would be required to fill out an unnecessary and complex form in order to collect the estimated $20 refund; courts are increasingly skeptical of such settlements because very few customers end up submitting a claim. 2. Any unclaimed settlement funds would go to insurance entities that are controlled by Farmers and were originally defendants in this case. The settlement provides no guarantee that the unclaimed funds will be used to benefit current policyholders, and giving the money to a Farmers affiliate clearly will not benefit policyholders who are no longer with the company. 3. The settlement bars claims by policyholders against the Farmers insurance affiliatesknown as the Exchanges, the beneficiaries of the unclaimed settlement funds.  Releasing the Exchanges from claims that class members may have against them is fundamentally improper, especially in light of the fact that the Exchanges apparently played some role in approving the excessive attorney in fact fee.  Discovery Request Denied.  On May 18, the Superior Court refused to allow the Intervenor, represented by Consumer Watchdog counsel, to conduct any discovery despite the fact that very little formal discovery had previously been conducted in the case.  Consumer Watchdog attorneys had sought documents, depositions of company officials, and other information about how Farmers’ parent company, the Swiss-based Zurich Financial Services, intends to use approximately $400 million in class action settlement proceeds supposedly intended for consumers. The Court subsequently approved the settlement.

Latest Farmers Price Optimization Articles


    KPIX-SF (CBS) – San Francisco, CA: Farmers Insurance Limits New Policies In California

    Harvey Rosenfield states that for the last 30 years, insurance companies have made four times the profit that they made nationally for selling homeowners coverage and thinks the insurance giants are trying to force state regulators to approve a rate hike.

    Why Loyal Customers May Be Paying More for Auto Insurance

    You could be paying higher premiums than a driver with a similar car and driving history. Here's why. By Kayda Norman, NERDWALLET June 25, 2020 https://www.thestreet.com/personal-finance/why-loyal-customers-may-be-paying-more-auto-insurance You expect your car insurance rates to increase after you buy a new vehicle, cause a...

    Commissioner Lara Should Reject Farmers’ Auto Insurance Rate Hikes and Stop Surcharges Aimed At COVID-19 First Responders and Emergency Workers, Says Consumer Watchdog

    Los Angeles, CA – Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara should reject Farmers Insurance Group’s proposed 6.5–6.9% auto insurance rate increases and its 3-tiered rating system based on occupation under which first responders and essential workers on the front lines...

    How Auto Insurers Use Your Nondriving Habits To Raise Prices

    By Kayda Norman, ASSOCIATED PRESS / NERD WALLET February 26, 2020 https://www.thetelegraph.com/business/article/How-auto-insurers-use-your-nondriving-habits-to-15085823.php You expect your car insurance rates to increase after you buy a new vehicle, cause a crash or add a young driver to your policy. But some insurers jack...

    How Auto Insurers Use Your Nondriving Habits to Raise Prices

    Safe, loyal drivers aren't always rewarded with cheaper rates. By Kayda Norman, NERDWALLET January 21, 2010 https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/insurance/price-optimization/ You expect your car insurance rates to increase after you buy a new vehicle, cause a crash or add a young driver to your policy....

    California to Hold Hearing on Alleged Overcharging by Farmers Insurance

    By Timothy Darragh, BESTWIRE May 21, 2019 http://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?altsrc=108&refnum=217240 Farmers Insurance Exchange and an affiliate will face a public hearing next month to answer allegations they systematically overcharged their long-time California automobile insurance customers. A panel of Los Angeles Superior Court judges May...

    Farmers Insurance Is Caught Overcharging Its Most Loyal Customers in Violation of Proposition 103

    Los Angeles, CA -- Farmers Insurance systematically overcharged its most loyal, longtime California customers from 2008 to 2018, according to evidence uncovered as part of an investigation ordered by the California Insurance Commissioner. Now, with a public hearing scheduled for...

    Farmers Insurance Asks Court To Block State Review Of Auto Rates And A Possible Refund Order

    Farmers Insurance has asked a court to block a state review of its auto insurance rates dating to 2008, making it the latest case to test the limits of California’s landmark insurance law, Proposition 103. The Woodland Hills firm,...

    Litigation In The News

    Support Consumer Watchdog

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.