State Reports Show That Robot Cars Aren’t Ready For Public Roads

Published on

Los Angeles—New reports required by the California Department of Motor Vehicles from companies testing robot cars on the state’s public roads show the technology is not ready to operate without a human who can take control of the car, Consumer Watchdog said today. The disengagement reports reveal how many times a human driver had to take control of the robot car during testing on public roads. Companies such as Uber needed human intervention at least once per every mile driven, but Waymo and Cruise were able to drive thousands of miles before intervention was needed.  

“Despite all of the hype and promises, these reports show that robot cars aren’t safe without human drivers ready to take over” said Adam Scow, Senior Advocate for Consumer Watchdog. “While some companies are gradually improving, others are crawling out of the gates. Much more testing and improvement is needed before regulators can consider approving driverless cars for our roads.” 

In 2018 robot cars were driven and tested for over 2 million miles on California public roads, a big increase from the 500,000 miles driven in 2017. Waymo, formerly Google’s autonomous vehicle unit, logged the majority of those miles with approximately 1.25 million miles. It reported a test driver took control 76 times, or once every 16,447 miles. The failure rate is significantly better than the 2017 period when Waymo’s robot cars drove 352,544 miles on California’s roads and reported 63 disengagements, or one every 5,596 miles. Last October Waymo became the only company to receive a permit to test without a human driver in the vehicle. 

In 2018 General Motors’ Cruise division, which previously claimed it would put robot cars on the road in 2019, drove 447,621 miles in San Francisco and had 86 human interventions or one every 5205 miles. 

Reports from Uber and Mercedes-Benz showed much higher rates of intervention. Uber reported a whopping 70,165 interventions for only 26,899 autonomous miles tested, or 2.6 human interventions per mile driven. Mercedes reported 1194 interventions for only 1749 miles tested or one intervention for every 1.46 miles driven

Details about the interventions include precaution, location, software and perception problems arising from a variety of scenarios. 

In addition to human intervention, State reports showed an increase in the amount of crashes involving the robot cars, which were reported to the DMV and posted on its website. Companies reported 75 collisions in 2018, compared to 29 reports in 2017. Cruise reported 22 crashes in 2017 and 36 in 2018.

While 62 companies are licensed to test autonomous vehicles in California, only those  companies that tested on public roads reported disengagement numbers for 2018. Tesla claimed it tests on public roads around the world, but did not report any tests in California. 

Consumer Watchdog praised the Department of Motor Vehicles for requiring and posting the disengagement reports and the crash reports.   Other states where testing is being done, including Arizona, Washington, Michigan and Pennsylvania, have no such disclosure requirement.

“Besides the occasional tragedy, the public is in the dark about what’s happening in other states. It’s only because of California’s rules that the public can find out what’s happening when companies use public roads as their private laboratories,” said Scow.  “The next step is to require that companies testing robot cars that are involved in a crash should be required to make public video and technical data about the incident.”

View the 2018 disengagement reports here: 

https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/vr/autonomous/disengagement_report_2018

– 30 –

Latest Privacy Videos
Video thumbnail
KCAL-LA - Los Angeles, CA: Personal Data Used To Target Shoppers
06:36
Video thumbnail
KCBA (FOX) - Monterey, CA: CA Bill Aims To Put An End To Surveillance Price Gouging
00:55
Video thumbnail
KLAS-LV (CBS) - Las Vegas, NV: Surveillance Pricing
00:46
Video thumbnail
KIRO-SEA (CBS) - Seattle, WA: CA Lawmakers Consider Bill On Price Gouging
00:51
Video thumbnail
AB 446 Press Conference
13:52
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Surveillance Pricing
02:07
Video thumbnail
KTTV-LA (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA: Prices Are being Adjusted Based On Your Shopping Habits
03:42
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: Surveillance Price Gouging
05:49
Video thumbnail
KCAL-LA - Los Angeles, CA: Surveilance Price Gouging
03:17
Video thumbnail
KBCW 44 Cable 12 - San Francisco, CA: Meta Holiday Hack
03:25
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: Several Tech Bills Head To Governor's Desk
06:12
Video thumbnail
Al Jazeera: Google antitrust law trial US court says google is a monopolist, violated law
02:16
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert — National Data Breach
01:24
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: Calm App, Doordash Software Sued For Data Sharing
05:40
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: No Opt Out
00:49
Video thumbnail
KCAL-LA - Los Angeles, CA: Investigation Into California's Newborn DNA Database
03:39
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Data Parasites
02:07
Video thumbnail
KCBS - Los Angeles, CA: California Biobank Stores Every Baby's DNA; Parents Had No Idea
04:26
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Wall Street using AI
01:48
Video thumbnail
KCBA (FOX) CA: Clearview AI Is Creating An AI Facial Recognition Software That Violates Privacy Laws
00:35
Video thumbnail
KGO CA: Consumer Watchdog Calls Attorney General to Investigate Clearview AI For Violating State Law
03:06
Video thumbnail
KNTV-SF (NBC) - San Francisco, CA: Tesla Recalls Millions of Cars
02:29
Video thumbnail
Consumer Alert: Clearview AI
01:19
Video thumbnail
Californians Now Have More Power Over Their Data
01:07
Video thumbnail
KPIX CBS TV-5 San Francisco, CA: Your Car's Computer Could Be Tracking And Reporting Your Every Move
00:48
Video thumbnail
California Votes YES on Privacy- Prop 24
13:14
Video thumbnail
Rage For Justice Report Podcast- Prop 24 For Your Privacy
19:18
Video thumbnail
Consumer Watchdog Hacks Tesla
02:00
Video thumbnail
FOX KSWB: New Internet-Connected Cars Could Get Hacked
01:05
Video thumbnail
ABC: Kill Switch Report Highlights Widespread Hacking Vulnerability of Connected Cars
02:12
Video thumbnail
KTTV FOX: Consumer Watchdog Report Warns That Hackers Can Take Over Your Car
05:02
Video thumbnail
SPECNEWS1: Watchdog Warns Cars With Internet Connection Vulnerable to Hacking
00:37
Video thumbnail
KBCW: Connected Cars Pose Risk to Driver Safety Due to Hacking Vulnerability
02:31
Video thumbnail
ABC KGO: Whistleblower Engineers Warn Connected Cars Need A Kill Switch to Stop Hacking
02:10
Video thumbnail
KCAL: Alarming Watchdog Report Shows Connected Cars Are Vulnerable to Hacking
02:51
Video thumbnail
ABC KGTV: Report Says Internet-Linked Cars Are Vulnerable To Hackers
00:30
Video thumbnail
KTTV Fox 11: Consumer Watchdog Report Shows How Vulnerable Connected Cars Are To Dangerous Hacking
01:05
Video thumbnail
NBC: Watchdog Report Show Connected Cars Lack of Cybersecurity Put Drivers at Risk
03:38
Video thumbnail
CBS KGPE: Connected Cars Pose A Cybersecurity Risk
03:05
Video thumbnail
Fox WDAF: High-Tech Cars Put Drivers At Risk Of Hacking Interference
00:47
Video thumbnail
ABC WXYZ: Connected Cars Can Be Hacked Says Kill Switch Report
01:36
Video thumbnail
KTTV GDLA: US Senators Write NHTSA About Connected Car Concerns
01:17
Video thumbnail
FOX KPTV: Kill Switch Report Details Cybersecurity Issues With Internet Connected Cars
02:28
Video thumbnail
CBS LA: Kill Switch Study Finds Connected Cars Are Vulnerable to Hacking
01:41
Video thumbnail
FOX KTTV: Consumer Watchdog on Privacy Issues, Hacking Risks With Internet-Connected Toys
03:00
Video thumbnail
CBS Evening News With Norah O'Donnell: Jamie Court Explains the Value of CA's Consumer Privacy Act
02:04
Video thumbnail
WAFF TV-48 Alabama: Watchdog Report Highlights Car-Hacking Risks
03:16
Video thumbnail
ABC KFSN: Internet-Connected Vehicles At Risk Of Being Hacked Says New Watchdog Report
00:33
Video thumbnail
KPIX CBS: Connected Cars Need A Kill Switch To Stop Dangerous Hacking
02:31
Video thumbnail
KCAL: Kill Switch Report Warns of Hacking Risk For Connected Cars
01:29

Privacy In The News

Latest Privacy Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.