Insurance Companies Use Unlawful Policy Provisions to Burn Homeowners on Wildfire Claims: Report

Published on

Los Angeles, CA — A Consumer Watchdog examination of public filings reveals that insurance companies have inserted provisions into the fine print of their home, condo and renters’ insurance policies that allow them to limit or deny coverage after a wildfire in violation of California law. Read the report, “Up in Smoke: How Insurance Companies and the Insurance Commissioner Burn Wildfire Victims,” here: https://www.consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/UP%20IN%20SMOKE%20report%20July%2011.pdf

Among the provisions are:

  • Limits on “Smoke Damage” Recovery – Smoke is often the most common and costly result of wildfires. Insurance companies have adopted policy provisions that treat “smoke damage” as separate from “fire damage” and limit compensation for smoke damage to far less than the total policy coverage for fire.
  • Arbitrary Loss Reporting Triggers – State law only requires policyholders to report a loss in a timely manner. Instead of setting the timeframe to report based on the date of the loss, some insurance companies arbitrarily base the reporting trigger on another event, such as the “start date of the wildfire,” potentially resulting in the company denying a claim as late.
  • Sub-limits on Recovery – California law requires fire insurance policies to cover “all loss by fire.” But some companies limit compensation if a homeowner misses a reporting deadline or based on the type of fire loss (as, for example, smoke damage sub-limits noted above).
  • Inception of Coverage Exclusions – These provisions say that a policyholder has no coverage for wildfire losses that occur within a certain time after the policy was purchased (usually 72 hours).
  • Appraisal Provisions Preventing Suit – Such provisions prevent a policyholder from suing an insurance company in court over a claim dispute either (1) without first going through a loss appraisal process; or (2) after going through appraisal. 

All of these provisions are unlawful under California law. Consumer Watchdog has also discovered that many insurers are unlawfully failing to notify policyholders of their legal rights after a government-declared wildfire disaster.

Update 8/22: The California FAIR Plan and at least five insurance companies — Nationwide, AAA SoCal, CSE Insurance Group, Falls Lake, and Liberty Insurance — currently have illegal limits or exclusions on smoke coverage according to the SERFF Filing Access website. SERFF is the electronic system insurers use to submit filings, including rates and forms, to the Department of Insurance for approval.
 
These companies and the FAIR Plan cover approximately 1.3 million California home, condo and apartment policyholders, representing approximately 15% of the homeowners insurance market.
 
Consumer Watchdog has identified at least seven additional companies through SERFF — Farmers, Mid-Century, Fire Insurance Exchange, Travelers, MAPFRE, Homesite and First American – whose policies contained smoke exclusions when record-breaking fire seasons began pummeling consumers in 2017. These companies have since updated their policies, and one will end business in California this year. However, claims filed and decided when these illegal provisions were in place could have improperly denied Californians coverage and must be reviewed, said the group.

Indeed, an internal audit of the FAIR Plan, conducted by California Department of Insurance investigators, confirms that FAIR Plan policies contain provisions limiting compensation for “smoke damage” – and that they violate California law. 

Consumer Advocates See Unlawful Claims Practices
 

California regulators, who are required to review home insurance policies for compliance with state law, should never have allowed these policies to be sold, said Consumer Watchdog. Policy provisions that allow companies to deny or restrict coverage directly affect rates and premiums. Thus, under insurance reform Proposition 103, insurance companies must submit such policies to the Commissioner, justify the rates they propose to charge for those policies, and obtain the Commissioner’s approval.

“The financial harm and personal trauma that homeowners experience when their insurance company refuses to pay legitimate claims is incalculable,” said Harvey Rosenfield, the author of Proposition 103, and founder of Consumer Watchdog. “Insurance companies have lowballed payments or denied coverage altogether when people filed a claim after the horrendous wildfires that swept the state in recent years. The frustration and heartbreak of fighting with an insurance company over the insurance coverage you already paid for can be as bad as the catastrophe itself. Insurance Commissioner Lara must take immediate actions to rectify this gross injustice and enforce the law.” 

Insurance Commissioner Lara has scheduled a public hearing on the FAIR Plan on Wednesday, July 13, 2022, at 9 am in Oakland. 

 

Demand for Commissioner Lara’s Immediate Action

Consumer Watchdog called on Commissioner Lara to: (1) stop approving policies that are illegal; (2) use the full authority of his office to get insurance companies to reopen and pay claims that were reduced or denied on unlawful grounds (as Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi did after the 1991 Oakland Hills fires); (3) levy maximum financial penalties against insurance companies that broke the law; and (4) investigate and seek criminal prosecution of the companies and corporate executives who defrauded policyholders, including for conspiracy to reduce coverages in violation of state antitrust laws. The organization also called for an independent audit of the agency’s failure to recognize and stop the illegal conduct.

Since taking office in January 2019, Insurance Commissioner Lara has made a point to visit communities devastated by wildfires and has repeatedly pledged to protect Californians against wildfire insurance abuses. Regulations have been proposed, but not yet adopted, that would require insurance companies to give homeowners a discount on their premiums for reducing the risk of their homes and property, and Consumer Watchdog has urged the Commissioner to close a dangerous loophole in their language.
 
Read Consumer Watchdog’s Report here: https://www.consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/UP%20IN%20SMOKE%20report%20July%2011.pdf
 
Read the CDI FAIR Plan audit here: https://consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/CA%20FAIR%20PLAN%20ASSOCIATION%20-%2003-18-21%20-%20Report.pdf
 
Read Consumer Watchdog’s Comments on the latest draft homeowner regulations proposed by Commissioner Lara here: https://consumerwatchdog.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/2022-07-01%20CWD%20Comments%20REG-2020-00015.pdf

Consumer Watchdog is a non-profit, non-partisan organization that has monitored the insurance industry and the Insurance Commissioner’s compliance with California law since the voters’ passage of insurance reform Proposition 103 in 1988. The organization defends and enforces Proposition 103 in the courts and at the California Department of Insurance. The organization’s challenges to excessive auto, home and business insurance rates have saved Californians over $3.48 billion since 2004.

– 30 –

Harvey Rosenfield
Harvey Rosenfield
As Consumer Watchdog's founder, Harvey Rosenfield is one of the nation's foremost consumer advocates. Trained as a public interest lawyer, Rosenfield authored Proposition 103 and organized the campaign that led to its passage by California voters in 1988 despite over $80 million spent in opposition (still a record).

Latest Insurance Videos

Video thumbnail
Will California protect homeowners from insurance company blackmail?
02:17
Video thumbnail
Spectrum News 1 (San Fernando Valley) - Los Angeles, CA: Fire Insurance Affordability
03:51
Video thumbnail
KGO(ABC)-San Francisco, CA: Consumer Watchdog and the Insurance Commissioner's Office Are In A Brawl
03:12
Video thumbnail
KNBC-LA (NBC) - Los Angeles, CAL: CA To Consider New Rules For Property Insurance Pricing
01:49
Video thumbnail
KPIX-SF (CBS) - San Francisco, CA: Insurance Overhaul
03:06
Video thumbnail
NBC Nightly News: Climate Change Driving Up Home Insurance
01:55
Video thumbnail
KCAL-LA - Los Angeles, CA: Insurance for High Risk Areas
03:02
Video thumbnail
KTLA-LA (CW) - Los Angeles, CA: Insurance Companies Offering Coverage In CA Fire Zones Again
00:48
Video thumbnail
KXTV-SAC (ABC) - Sacramento, CA: Changes Coming to Home Insurance Market
02:32
Video thumbnail
KCBS-LA (CBS) - Los Angeles, CA: CA Insurance Pricing Proposal
02:08
Video thumbnail
KCRA3 - Sacramento, CA: California Lawmakers to Hold Hearings on Homeowners Insurance Crisis
02:28
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: California Home Insurance Crisis
05:24
Video thumbnail
KMPH(FOX) - Fresno, CA: Insurance Industry's Focus Will Now Shift to Insurance Commissioner Lara
00:37
Video thumbnail
KPIX-SF (CBS) - San Francisco, CA: Deadline Passes for Insurance Legislation
05:17
Video thumbnail
KNTV-SF (NBC) - San Francisco, CA: Insurance Limbo
02:49
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: Insurance Bailout Deal Fails
00:28
Video thumbnail
KGO-SF (ABC) - San Francisco, CA: Insurance Legislation Efforts
03:02
Video thumbnail
KCBA (FOX) - Monterey, CA: Insurance Lobbyists and CA Lawmakers Are Trying to Strike a Deal
00:33
Video thumbnail
KTTV-LA (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA: California Home Insurance Crisis
04:47
Video thumbnail
KGO-SF, CA: Consumer Advocates Have Been Excluded From Negotiations by the Insurance Industry
02:57
Video thumbnail
KNBC - Los Angeles, CA: Car Insurance Rates Soaring
03:01
Video thumbnail
KCBA (FOX) - Monterey, CA: Insurers Are Working on a Secret Plan to Gut Current State Insurance Law
02:57
Video thumbnail
KPBS-San Diego, CA: Homeowner Insurance Companies are Leaving CA and Consumer Advocates Want Answers
02:59
Video thumbnail
KTVU(FOX) CA: Insurance Companies Coordinated an Effort to Stop Providing Homeowners Insurance in CA
00:30
Video thumbnail
ABC7 - Los Angeles, CA: How Can Insurance in California be Reformed?
03:19
Video thumbnail
KMPH-FRES (FOX) - Fresno, CA: CA Homeowners Insurance Crisis
01:53
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: Recording Reveals Potential Wildfire Bailout
00:58
Video thumbnail
KGO-SF (ABC) - San Francisco, CA: Secret Recording
02:40
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: California Insurers Want Deregulation
03:27
Video thumbnail
Insurance Lobbyist Taped Bragging About 11th Hour Legislative "Surprise" For Industry Bailout
01:04
Video thumbnail
KNBC-LA (NBC) - Los Angeles, CA: Car Insurance Rates Soaring
03:01
Video thumbnail
KFMB-SD (CBS) - San Diego, CA: Bracing for the Burn
05:17
Video thumbnail
KPIX-SF (CBS) - San Francisco, CA: Financial Risks in a Troubled insurance Market
03:52
Video thumbnail
KPBS - Los Angeles, CA: California's Homeowners Insurance Crisis is Spreading to Car Insurance
05:25
Video thumbnail
KPIX-SF (CBS) - San Francisco, CA: Farmers Insurance Limits New Policies In California
03:15
Video thumbnail
KTVU-SF (FOX) - San Francisco, CA: The Struggle to Find Homeowners Insurance
02:52
Video thumbnail
KGO-SF (ABC) - San Francisco, CA: Mileage Creep Warning
02:30
Video thumbnail
KPBS Television - San Diego, CA: Insurance Companies are Using Scare Tactics
03:03
Video thumbnail
KABC-LA (ABC) - Los Angeles, CA: Allstate and State Farms Profits Are Four Times the National Averag
02:32
Video thumbnail
KCAL-LA - Los Angeles, CA: Allstate & State Farm Are Requesting Massive Rate Hikes
04:13
Video thumbnail
KGO-SF (ABC) - San Francisco, CA: Farmers Insurance Halts New Homeowner Policies in CA
04:11
Video thumbnail
KTLA-LA (CW) - Los Angeles, CA: Allstate Pauses New Insurance Policies
03:28
Video thumbnail
FOX - LA, CA: StateFarm Broke the Law With Their Decision to Stop Serving New Homeowners Policies
04:42
Video thumbnail
KPIX-SF (CBS) - San Francisco, CA: State Farm is Trying to Lead an Insurance Insurrection
02:52
Video thumbnail
KABC-LA, CA: What's the Ulterior Motive Behind State Farm's Removal of New Insurance Policies in CA?
02:36
Video thumbnail
KGO(ABC) - San Francisco, CA: Insurance Companies Are Counting Mileage and Increasing Rates
03:47
Video thumbnail
KFMB (CBS 8) - Calls for Insurance Commissioner Lara To Take Action Against State Farm
01:01
Video thumbnail
KTTV-LA (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA; State Farm Car Insurance Policies Going Up By 7%
00:31
Video thumbnail
KSBY, CA; Estimated $5.5 Billion Was Overcharged To Californians Across Top 15 Insurance Providers
02:31
Video thumbnail
KABC-LA (ABC) - Los Angeles, CA; Insurance Companies Owe Consumers Billions
00:56

Latest Insurance Releases

Insurance In The News

Latest Privacy Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Insurance Releases