Consumer Watchdog · Investigation
Coordinating a Supreme Court Campaign to Shield Big Oil
Thirty-eight organizations urged the U.S. Supreme Court to shield Exxon and Suncor from climate deception lawsuits. Consumer Watchdog found that two-thirds are financially connected to fossil fuel companies, fossil fuel billionaires, or the climate denial networks that spent decades helping create the deception at the heart of these lawsuits. And sixteen amici supporting defendants ExxonMobil and Suncor received funding tied to the defendants—either directly from ExxonMobil or from entities linked to Paul Singer, whose Elliott Investment Management is a major Suncor investor.
Scroll to follow the money↓
THE NETWORK
Thirty-eight organizations filed briefs supporting Exxon and Suncor. Consumer Watchdog found 25 of them — 66% — received funding from fossil fuel companies, fossil fuel billionaires, or foundations and dark-money networks that financed climate denial and opposition to climate accountability for decades.
EXXON KNEW
Exxon isn’t just a defendant accused of deceiving the public about climate change. It also has documented funding, governance, or leadership ties to 11 organizations that filed Supreme Court briefs supporting its legal position.
PAUL SINGER, FOSSIL FUEL BILLIONAIRE
Singer’s hedge fund, Elliott Management, holds about $2.3 billion in Suncor stock, making it one of Suncor’s largest investors. Singer’s foundation contributed nearly $478 million to a donor-advised fund administered by National Philanthropic Trust (NPT). During the same period, NPT awarded more than $12 million to nine Suncor amici.
THE FOSSIL FUEL FUNDED KOCH NETWORK
For decades, Charles Koch’s network has financed organizations opposing climate regulation and clean energy. Through Stand Together Trust, DonorsTrust, Donors Capital Fund, the Charles Koch Foundation, and related entities, the Koch network funded more Suncor amici than any other fossil fuel funding network identified in this report at 16 groups.
FOSSIL FUEL FUNDED FORTUNES
The Sarah Scaife Foundation (10 groups) — built from the Mellon family’s oil, coal, banking and industrial wealth — and other fossil fuel billionaires including coal executive Joe Craft and oil CEO Harold Hamm helped finance two additional organizations supporting Exxon and Suncor. These funders have spent years backing campaigns opposing climate science, environmental regulation, and corporate accountability.
THE LEGAL MACHINE
The Leonard Leo network helped build the legal infrastructure behind many of these briefs. Nine organizations funded through the 85 Fund, Concord Fund, and related nonprofits are now asking the Supreme Court to make it harder for states and communities to hold fossil fuel companies accountable for misleading the public about the climate dangers of their products.
OLD MONEY
For decades, the Bradley (16 groups) and Searle (8 groups) foundations financed organizations that questioned climate science, opposed environmental regulation, and helped build the intellectual case against climate action. Today, many of those same organizations are asking the Supreme Court to shield fossil fuel companies from lawsuits alleging they deceived the public about climate change.
ONE NETWORK
These organizations present themselves as independent voices before the Supreme Court. Consumer Watchdog’s investigation found many are financed by the same fossil fuel companies, billionaire investors, and climate denial networks that spent decades disputing or downplaying the fossil fuel industry’s role in climate change. Now, they are asking the Court to make it harder to hold those same companies accountable for deceiving the public about those risks.
Read the full report →The case files↓
The case files
The organizations behind the briefs, and the money behind them — sorted into three kinds of backer: the fossil fuel defendants and their investors (Exxon, Paul Singer, National Philanthropic Trust), the broader fossil fuel industry money (Koch, Scaife, Craft, Hamm), and the climate denial foundations and dark-money networks (Leo, Bradley, Searle). Filter by backer to drill down, or open any file for its dossier.