The question of where to house a proposed new consumer protection agency has garnered at least as much attention as whether there is a genuine need for such an agency. “The Fed has a dismal record on consumer protection,” said Carmen
Balber, director of Consumer Watchdog's Washington, D.C., office. Consumer Watchdog supports a stand-alone consumer protection agency. “We
have argued from the start that to be truly independent, a consumer
protection agency needs to be a stand-alone entity. Dodd’s bill attempts to insulate the proposed agency from
undue influence within the Fed by allowing the president to appoint its
leadership and by making its budget wholly separate from the Fed’s
budget," said Balber. There are other well-intentioned “firewalls” designed to curtail Fed
influence, according to Balber. “But it’s not enough,” she said. “At
the end of the day it’s hard to see a bureau of the Federal Reserve
that’s not influenced by Ben Bernanke.”