Consumer Watchdog

Expose. Confront. Change.

Consumer Watchdog

Did stem cell agency learn from Klein-Ortiz flap?

Has then California stem cell agency finally learned the value of good relations with the State Legislature? Maybe so.

Back in 2006 then Senate Heath Committee Chairman Deborah Ortiz offered  SB 401 aimed at fixing some of the agency’s governance problems and seeking to ensure affordable access for Californians to the fruits of the stem cell research they’re paying $6 billion for.

The stem cell oversight committee passed a resolution opposing SB 401. And Chairman Bob Klein railed against Ortiz (opens in new tab).  About to be termed out of office, she was seeking the Democratic nomination for Secretary of State.

On the eve of the primary election Klein fired off a letter to patient advocates charging that Ortiz was on an "anti-research crusade."

This year current Health Committee Chairman Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-23) and Sen. George Runner (R-17) have introduced their version of stem cell agency oversight legislation, SB 1565.

I testified in support of the measure (opens in new tab) in Sacramento on Wednesday before it was approved unanimously by the Health Committee.  Donna Gerber of the California Nurses Association also spoke in favor. It moves next to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Instead of the food fight between Klein and Ortiz, this year’s stem cell agency response is far more temperate.  The  agency’s Interim  Legislative Director, Sue North, told the Health Committee, "We have no formal position on the bill and hope to resolve any differences administratively."

It’s about time the stem cell agency leadership cooled off, acted like adults and realized the Legislature has a legitimate role to play.

John M. Simpson

John M. Simpson

John M. Simpson is an American consumer rights advocate and former journalist. Since 2005, he has worked for Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan nonprofit public interest group, as the lead researcher on Inside Google, the group's effort to educate the public about Google's dominance over the internet and the need for greater online privacy.

All Articles →