Consumer Watchdog

Expose. Confront. Change.

Consumer Watchdog

CPUC Proposal Would Hand PG&E $456 Million Without a Complete Record, as Utility Cuts $2 Billion in Spending and Projects Higher Profits

CPUC Proposal Would Hand PG&E 6 Million Without a Complete Record, as Utility Cuts  Billion in Spending and Projects Higher Profits

San Francisco, CA — Consumer Watchdog filed comments (opens in new tab) on the California Public Utilities Commission proposed decision that would let Pacific Gas and Electric Company collect $456 million in interim rate increases starting January 1, 2027, before the Commission has examined PG&E’s own announcement that it is cutting roughly $2 billion from its 2027 investment plan. The proposed decision is slated to be voted on by the Commission on Thursday. 

According to Consumer Watchdog’s comments on the Commission’s Proposed Decision, PG&E is spending less, borrowing less, and telling investors to expect higher earnings, yet the Commission is poised to make customers pay more right now. Regulators are being asked to approve money for work PG&E has already said it won’t do, and they have not even looked at the evidence.

Consumer Watchdog urged Commissioner Matthew Baker to withdraw the proposed decision, return it to the Administrative Law Judges, rule on the Public Advocates’ motion about the “incomplete record” first, and require PG&E to disclose exactly which projects it is deferring before any rate increase is approved. 

“The record for the interim rate hike changed when PG&E pulled back its planned $2 billion in infrastructure, but the proposed decision doesn’t address that pullback,” said Jamie Court, president of Consumer Watchdog. “Ratepayers shouldn’t get a bill before the utilities are forced to justify what ratepayers are getting for that money.” 

Less spending, more profit, but a bigger bill

On September 2, PG&E announced it would defer about $2 billion in planned 2027 investment, reducing its borrowing needs by the same amount. In the same announcement, its parent company projected 2027 earnings of $1.78 to $1.82 per share, up from $1.64 to $1.66 in 2026. PG&E’s own filings tout 10.6% earnings-per-share growth in 2024 and a 65% three-year return to shareholders. According to Public Advocates Office, PG&E has even said it can fund critical safety work in part by “retaining earnings to re-invest in the company.” 

The proposed decision itself concedes that PG&E faces no financial emergency. Its main justification is that collecting money early could save customers an estimated $13.6 million to $21.0 million in interest. But those savings assume PG&E spends what it originally forecast. With $2 billion in work now on hold, that assumption no longer holds.

A decision that ignores the elephant in the room

On October 23, the Commission’s own Public Advocates Office filed a motion warning that it is “unjust and unreasonable to set rates with an incomplete record” after PG&E’s announcement. The Public Advocates found that PG&E “has failed to identify which of its forecast projects will be reduced or eliminated,” and PG&E admitted it is “still in the process of evaluating and identifying the specific programs to be deferred.” Even PG&E acknowledges the “unique situation” its announcement created.

The proposed decision does not address any of this. It never discusses the $2 billion deferral, PG&E’s strategic review, or the pending motion. Instead, it approves interim rates based on spending forecasts that PG&E itself has called into question.

According to Consumer Watchdog, a promise of refunds later is no substitute for getting the numbers right first. Customers should not be asked to finance PG&E’s cash flow while the company refuses to say what it is cutting.   

Singleton Schreiber is co-counsel with Consumer Watchdog in the matter. 

Consumer Watchdog · November 18, 2026
https://consumerwatchdog.org/energy/cpuc-proposal-would-hand-pge-456-million-without-a-complete-record-as-utility-cuts-2-billion-in-spending-and-projects-higher-profits/
© 2026 Consumer Watchdog. Printed November 18, 2026.

Jamie Court

Consumer Watchdog's President and Chairman of the Board is an award-winning and nationally recognized consumer advocate. The author of three books, he has led dozens of campaigns to reform insurance companies, financial institutions, energy companies, political accountability and health care companies.

All Articles →