How California’s Failed Recycling Program Has Hurt Local Consumers

Published on


April 30, 2022

Frustrated readers have written me that it’s become increasingly hard to turn in bottles and cans for cash as recycling redemption centers have seemed to disappear.

“I thought that bottle recycle fees were originally added to our grocery bills with the expectation that they would lead to less littering because people would collect them for the money,” a woman emailed me. “If one wanted to collect bottles for recycling, how could it be done now (without spending more in gas money than one would be rebated)?” 

“I do not think it is fair we are charged a deposit when it cannot be redeemed,” another said. “It is a way of supplementing the income for many people.” 

These readers are onto something. 

“The bottle deposit is the principal recycling tool in the state, and it’s been left to languish.” Jamie Court 

My colleague Mary Callahan recently dug into the 35-year-old “Bottle Bill” program where consumers pay a 5- or 10-cent fee on containers that can be recouped when the cans and bottles are turned in at recycling centers or retailers. 

Overall, bottle bills have proved an effective recycling incentive in the 10 states that have implemented them. 

But in California, the shuttering of almost half of container redemption sites over the past decade has made it difficult for residents to cash in, leading to $635 million in unclaimed deposits sitting with the state. 

“When you make it so inconvenient, people give up on it.” Jamie Court 

Sonoma County lost almost 85% of its recycling centers in the past 10 years, and some Northern California counties have none. In Marin County, each site serves 131,000 people on average, according to data from the Container Recycling Institute. 

“It’s been disastrous for consumers because they’ve basically been in a situation where they haven’t had a way of getting their deposits back,” said Jamie Court, president of Consumer Watchdog, an advocacy nonprofit. 

“When you make it so inconvenient, people give up on it.” 

A three-month Consumer Watchdog investigation in 2019 found that “for every nickel bottle deposit that California consumers pay in the checkout line, they only get back 2.65 cents.” 

Having a functioning redemption program is particularly important to environmental goals given that curbside recycling is often contaminated and unfit or difficult to reprocess. Sometimes it just ends up in landfills. 

“The bottle deposit is the principal recycling tool in the state, and it’s been left to languish,” Court told me. “When we lost all those redemption centers, there was nothing to fill the void.” 

The Bottle Bill system is struggling for a number of reasons that Callahan laid out, many of which are tied to the fact that California runs the program instead of the beverage industry like in almost all other states. 

But retailers and grocers have also played a central role in limiting options for consumers. By law, they’re required to redeem containers in-store when there’s no nearby recycling site (which has increasingly been the case). 

However, stores can opt out by paying a $100 daily fee to the state’s recycling program, an easy workaround that leaves would-be recyclers in the lurch. 

“The retailers which are legally required to pick up the slack aren’t doing it and haven’t done it for a long time,” Court said, “and the state’s not forcing them honestly.” 

(ZeroWaste Sonoma, Sonoma County’s waste management agency, has a list of county retailers that have opted out.) 

CalRecycle has reportedly granted chains more than 1,200 exemptions, almost half since 2013. Stores owned by Albertsons Companies Inc. such as Safeway, as well as Walmart Inc. and its subsidiary Sam’s Club have each been given more than 100 state exemptions. In 2019, CVS Pharmacy Inc. got hit with a $3.6 million penalty for failing to accept containers or pay the fee in a number of its California locations. 

Meanwhile, over time, the state has dipped into the unclaimed deposit pot for projects and funds unrelated to recycling, like balancing the general budget. It also recently got in hot water for misreporting the amount of accumulated funds. 

Policymakers now are taking several steps toward turning around the embattled system. California Senate Bill 38, which is under consideration by the Assembly after passing the Senate, would make beverage producers responsible for the redemption program. 

CalRecycle, which manages the state’s recycling program, has been launching redemption-related pilot programs, including one with Sonoma County to add up to 10 new redemption sites. The first just opened in Sebastopol and others are slated for Santa Rosa, Petaluma, Sonoma, Healdsburg and Cloverdale. 

The agency also is partnering with CVS to install 20 reverse vending machines at its stores in unserved areas in the state where consumers can redeem their deposits. 

In April, the state’s proposed budget to boost redemption via a variety of efforts using $330 million in surplus deposit funds was welcome news to many advocates. With so many proposals, though, some warn there’ll be a need to lean on experts, communities and data to ensure the money is used efficiently and effectively with an eye toward the program’s long-term sustainability. 


“In Your Corner” is a new column that puts watchdog reporting to work for the community. If you have a concern, a tip, or a hunch, you can reach “In Your Corner” Columnist Marisa Endicott at 707-521-5470 or [email protected] On Twitter @InYourCornerTPD and Facebook @InYourCornerTPD.

Consumer Watchdog
Consumer Watchdog
Providing an effective voice for American consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Non-partisan.

Latest Energy Videos

Video thumbnail
(CBS)-Fresno, CA; Victory For Californians As Bill Passes That Will Regulate Profits Of Oil Refiners
Video thumbnail
CNBC - Jamie Court Speaks About The Bill That Would Penalize Oil Refineries For Price Gouging
Video thumbnail
KXTV(ABC) - Sacramento, CA; Governor Newsom Announced A New Deal With Lawmakers To Take On Big Oil
Video thumbnail
KNBC-LA (NBC) - Los Angeles, CA; Holding Utility Companies Accountable For Power Outages
Video thumbnail
Consumer Watchdog at CA Senate Energy Cmte 2 22 23
Video thumbnail
KFMB CW - San Diego, CA; Oil Companies Need to be Held Accountable for High Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KTTV (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA; Recap Of Jamie Court's Testimony At The Senate Hearing For Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KGTV(ABC) - SD, CA; Jamie Court Will Testify at the Price Gouging Hearing for Rising Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KTTV-LA (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA; SoCal Gas Bill Sticker Shock
Video thumbnail
Spectrum News 1 - Los Angeles, CA; Who Is SoCal Gas Buying Their Gas From?
Video thumbnail
Why SoCal Gas is at Fault For Doubling Your Natural Gas Bill
Video thumbnail
KNBC - Los Angeles, CA; Spike In Natural Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KCBS - Los Angeles, CA; New Year, New Pain At The Pump
Video thumbnail
KCAL - Los Angeles, CA; Jamie Court Says We are Being Gouged By SoCal Gas
Video thumbnail
KTTV (FOX) - Los Angeles, CA; Jamie Court Weighs In On Astronomically High SoCal Gas Bills
Video thumbnail
KCAL- LA, CA; What's Behind The Gas Price Jump And Simple Changes That Could Save You Some Money
Video thumbnail
Spectrum News 1 - Los Angeles, CA; SoCal Gas Is Blaming Price Hikes On A Cold Snap
Video thumbnail
KCAL- Los Angeles, CA; SoCal Gas Price Hikes Has To Do With Mismanagement
Video thumbnail
Spectrum News 1 - Los Angeles, CA; Jamie Court Says There's More To The SoCal Price Hike
Video thumbnail
Consumer Watchdog President Jamie Court Testifies About Need for Windfall Profits Cap in California
Video thumbnail
Californians Need a Rebate From Gasoline Price Gouging
Video thumbnail
Senate Bill 1322 Takes On The Golden State Gouge
Video thumbnail
CBS Evening News: Jamie Court on Gas Prices Hitting 5 Year High
Video thumbnail
KNBC: Jamie Court Explains the Spike in Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KTTV-GDLA: Jamie Court Explains California's High Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
SPECTRUM NEWS1: Challenges Redeeming Recyclables in California
Video thumbnail
SPECTRUM NEWS1: California Stores Preventing Bottle Deposit Redemption
Video thumbnail
KCAL: Santa Monica's Last Recycling Center is Closing
Video thumbnail
KABC: New Gas Tax to be Enacted on July 1st
Video thumbnail
KTVU Fox: Consumer Watchdog Urges Governor Newsom to Fire Oil Regulators With Conflicts of Interests
Video thumbnail
SPECTRUM NEWS 1: DOGGR Regulator Fired Over Conflicts of Interest and Increased Oil Drilling Permits
Video thumbnail
KABC: FBI Raids LADWP Office and City Attorney's Office Over Billing Scandal Cover-Up
Video thumbnail
KABC: The Largest Chain of Recycling Centers in CA is Closing Down
Video thumbnail
ABC KOFY: CA's Recycling Crisis Worsens After Largest Chain of Recycling Centers Close
Video thumbnail
ABC KXTV: rePlanet Closes Entire Chain Of Recycling Centers
Video thumbnail
KRON: rePlanet Recycling Centers Shut Down Statewide
Video thumbnail
KTTV: rePlanet CA's Largest Recycling Business Closes All Sites Statewide
Video thumbnail
KSBY: Closure Of All rePlanet Recycling Centers Threatens Ability to Redeem Bottle Deposits
Video thumbnail
KPIX: CA Recycling Is Dealt A Blow As rePlanet Shuts Down Centers Statewide
Video thumbnail
KGO: CA Faces Recycling Woes As Largest Recycling Chain rePlanet Shuts Down
Video thumbnail
SPECNEWS1: Consumer Watchdog Addresses High Gas Prices In SoCal
Video thumbnail
KCBS: Governor Newsom Calls For AG To Investigate Skyrocketing Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KTTV: Consumer Watchdog Applauds Gov Newsom Request For Investigation Into CA Gas Prices
Video thumbnail
KNBC: Newsom Calls For An Investigation Into CA Gas Prices, Highest In Country
Video thumbnail
KABC: Newsom Wants A Probe Into CA Gas Price Fixing And Manipulation
Video thumbnail
CBS KOVR: Governor Newsom Orders Investigation Into High Gas Prices in CA
Video thumbnail
KABC Los Angeles: Consumer Watchdog on the Need to Overhaul CA's Failing Recycling Program
Video thumbnail
KCAL LA: Consumer Watchdog on the New Bill SB372 and the Collapse of CA's Bottle Redemption System
Video thumbnail
CBS SF: Consumer Watchdog Ranks CA's Bottle Deposit System Worst in Nation, SB372 Reaches Senate

Latest Energy Releases

Energy In The News

Latest Energy Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More energy Releases