HARVEY ROSENFIELD: Democracy Another ‘Casualty’ Of Pandemic?

Published on

By Carla Marinucci, Jeremy B. White, Graph Massara, and Aaron Leathley, POLITICO

August 10, 2020


THE BUZZ — DEMOCRACY AT STAKE? In a legislative season of firsts shaped by the coronavirus, California lawmakers  already struggling with a crush of bills, proxy voting and “virtual” governing — are now facing increasing criticism that they’re allowing democracy itself to become another casualty of the pandemic. 

Andrew Meredith, president of the Northeastern California Building and Construction Trades Council, told POLITICO he waited on the phone for an hour and 45 minutes during the meeting of the Senate Committee on Resources and Water last week to express his opposition to hotly contested Assembly Bill 345, sponsored by Democratic Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi. 

The bill called for the creation of an environmental justice program and consideration of a 2,500-foot setback from such oil and gas wells for schools, playgrounds and other public places where children are present. It was backed by environmentalists and health officials, but opposed by the oil and gas industry — and labor leaders like Meredith who argue it could cost thousands of good-paying jobs. “I never even made it to the point where I got a number,’’ Meredith said, adding he was cut off without warning, “and we still had 100 people who were opposed — and waiting to speak.’’

Meredith isn’t alone in his frustration.

Consumer Watchdog founder Harvey Rosenfield, the author of Prop. 103 — the 1988 landmark insurance initiative — charged in a letter to Senate Pro Tem Toni Atkins Friday that the legislature’s fast-tracking of bills under the Covid crisis has shortchanged public comment and testimony that’s essential to the process. 

Rosenfield said his experience came last week as he prepared to testify before the Senate Insurance Committee against AB 2167, legislation which he said is being pushed by the insurance industry to “override Proposition 103’s protections against price gouging and discriminatory practices and enable insurance companies to dramatically raise homeowners’ and renters insurance rates.’’

But he complained that — even as the author of the original ballot measure — “I was given exactly twenty seconds to articulate’’ his views, while “lobbyists for the insurance industry testified for five minutes.”

“It is clear that the current fast-track process for AB 2167 and the pandemic procedures in place have combined to deny even the bare minimum of public scrutiny required to adequately consider legislation,’’ Rosenfield said. 

As Jeff McDonald of the San Diego Union Tribune reports, Rosenfield is formally asking Atkins “to delay consideration of the legislation until next year,’’ when the matter of changes in insurance policy can get the “care and concern for California consumers that they require.” “We ask you not to allow democracy to become another casualty of the pandemic,’’ he wrote.

Meredith said he understands that interested citizens have the right to submit comment in writing. But, he argued, “there’s no substitute for hearing directly from the people on whether they support or oppose a bill.’’ He adds: “We’re supposed to have the ability to speak. That’s one of the tenants of democracy.’’

Atkins, in a statement to POLITICO, said: “My office received this letter from Consumer Watchdog yesterday. We will review the contents and respond as appropriate.”

Statement from Speaker Anthony Rendon’s spokeswoman Katie Talbot: “While we can’t comment on Senate committee procedures, throughout the COVID-19 pandemic the Assembly has offered an unprecedented level of accessibility to our committee hearings through phone testimony, in-person testimony, and remote testimony stations placed across the state.”

Consumer Watchdog
Consumer Watchdoghttps://consumerwatchdog.org
Providing an effective voice for American consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Non-partisan.

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases