Consumer Watchdog

Expose. Confront. Change.

Consumer Watchdog

Are Auto Insurers Charging Immigrants Extra?

Are Auto Insurers Charging Immigrants Extra?

It looks like legal immigrants who buy auto insurance in California may be getting a raw deal from at least some insurance companies. What we're hearing is that a few companies are refusing to give the state's Good Driver discount to immigrants who have held a U.S. drivers license for less than 18 months. Even drivers who can show a clean driving record.

We're trying to confirm that this ripoff is actually occurring. If you (or someone you know) immigrated within the last 5 years and obtained auto insurance before you had your California driver’s license for 18 months, you may have been overcharged by 20% or more. If so, please click here to tell us about it.

Why it's important:

  • The Good Driver discount can be worth hundreds of dollars a year, enough to make the difference between affordable and unaffordable auto insurance.
  • There's nothing in California law that says a driver has to be licensed in the U.S. for 18 months to qualify for the discount.
  • Denying the discount to a driver who can show a clean driving record would be a violation of California insurance laws.
  • Such denials may also violate California civil rights law.

So being denied this discount isn't trivial–it's fairly big money, and also a matter of equal treatment. If you're not sure, or you have a question, send us a message here.