Google: Self-Driving Cars Improve, But Still Need Human Help

Published on

LOS ANGELES _ Google’s futuristic self-driving cars needed some old-fashioned human intervention to avoid 11 crashes during testing on California roads, the company revealed Tuesday, results it says are encouraging but show the technology has yet to reach the goal of not needing someone behind the wheel.

With Google’s fleet logging tens of thousands of miles each month, the 11 instances would be the equivalent of a car having one event every three years, based on how much the average vehicle is driven in the U.S.

There were another 272 cases in which failures of the cars’ software or onboard sensors forced the person who must be in the front seat – just in case – to grab the wheel during roughly a year of testing.

Though Google did not release detailed scenarios, the problems included issues with the self-driving cars seeing traffic lights, yielding to pedestrians or committing traffic violations. There were also cases where intervention was needed because other drivers were reckless, and several dozen instances of an “unwanted maneuver” by Google’s car.

“We’re seeing lots of improvement. But it’s not quite ready yet,” said Chris Urmson, who heads Google’s self-driving car project. “That’s exactly why we test our vehicles with a steering wheel and pedals.”

Bryant Walker Smith, a professor at the University of South Carolina who closely follows self-driving car developments, said the rate of potential collisions was “not terribly high, but certainly not trivial.” He said it remains difficult to gauge how Google’s cars compare to accident rates among human drivers, since even the best data underreport minor collisions that are never reported to authorities.

While the problem rate is “impressively low,” a trained safety driver should remain in the front seat, said Raj Rajkumar, an engineering professor at Carnegie Mellon University who specializes in self-driving cars.

John Simpson, a frequent critic of Google who focuses on privacy issues for the nonprofit group Consumer Watchdog, said the report “underscores the need for a driver behind the steering wheel capable of taking control of the robot car.”

Google has argued to California regulators that once the company concludes the cars are ready for the public to use, they should not need a steering wheel or pedals because human intervention would actually make them less safe.

“It’s unfathomable that Google is pushing back” on the need for a wheel and pedals, Simpson said.

Seven companies with permission to test self-driving prototypes on California roads were required to report to the state’s Department of Motor Vehicles instances in which drivers had to take over due to technology problems or safety concerns.

The Associated Press has filed a public records act request for all the reports; the DMV has not formally replied and did not reply to a request for comment Tuesday.

Google released its report before the agency, or the other companies, in what it described as an effort to be transparent about its safety record. The company had lobbied against having to report “disengagements” from self-driving mode, saying the data could be misinterpreted.

In all, Google reported 341 total safety-related disengagements during 424,000 miles of testing, which took place mostly in neighborhoods near Google’s Silicon Valley headquarters or on the streets of Austin, Texas. Google ran 49 cars between September 2014, when California began formally allowing prototype testing in public, and the end of November.

With the average vehicle traveling about 12,000 miles each year, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation, a Google car required human intervention for one reason or another the equivalent of about 10 times per driving year. That rate has improved in recent months, according to Google data.

Google said its cars would have been responsible in eight of the 11 avoided accidents, according to computer modeling the company performed later. Among those eight, “There’s none where it was like, ‘Holy cow, we just avoided a big wreck,’” Urmson said. During this phase of testing, Google cars usually stay below 35 mph, although they also drive on highways.

Google cars have been involved in nine collisions since September 2014. In each case, the other car was responsible, according to an analysis by researchers at Virginia Tech University.
Contact Justin Pritchard at
Google’s report:
Google’s take on its data:

Latest Videos

Latest Releases

In The News

Latest Report

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Releases