Paul Ethier

He was a surfer, doing what he loved best: riding the California waves. The swell was up one day in 2004 off Half Moon Bay, sending the Paul Ethier’s board careening toward him. He was struck directly on the head. When the 29-year-old electrician managed to make his way out of the water, friends quickly carted him to the emergency room. A doctor sewed him up and sent him home with a prescription for pain medication. While there, Ethier collapsed with a brain hemorrhage that the doctor had failed to detect. After three nights in a coma, they disconnected him from life support.

His mother sang Paul lullabies as he passed away.

The family sought justice for what seemed like horribly substandard care. But the outdated law from 1975 that limits the compensation for victims of medical negligence stood in their way.

“Because of the cap we were lucky to get an attorney to take the case,” his mother says. The family learned that a simple X-ray would have demonstrated the extent of the damage. Plus, the ER doctor had a track record of similar cases with equally poor results.

The family pressed for trial, and a jury came back with an award of $3.1 million. But because of California’s damages cap, the judge later slashed the award to less than one-tenth of that. To the state of California, Paul Ethier’s life was worth just $250,000.

Protect patients from dangerous doctors.

Latest Patient Safety Videos

Video thumbnail
KGET - Consumer Watchdog Advocates Note The Importance of Making Change Within The Healthcare System
02:26
Video thumbnail
ABC - Bakersfield, CA; Consumer Watchdog Shows Support in Honor of the Latina Maternal Health Fair
02:53
Video thumbnail
KABC- Los Angeles, CA; Pathways Medical in Toluca Lake Owner Falsely Claims to be A Licensed Doctor
02:22
Video thumbnail
Spectrum News; CW Argues Senate Bill 815's Proposed Changes Aren't Enough To Protect Patients
02:39
Video thumbnail
Larcenia Taylor Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
01:20
Video thumbnail
Patricia Plascencia Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
03:00
Video thumbnail
Selah O'Connor Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:53
Video thumbnail
Sandy Perez Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:56
Video thumbnail
Selah O'Connor Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:53
Video thumbnail
Selena Alvarez Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:04
Video thumbnail
Judith Gorcey's Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:15
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:19
Video thumbnail
Robert Andrian Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:43
Video thumbnail
Evelen Martinez Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
00:42
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt Ramos Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
01:33
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:11
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt Sunset Review Testimony
02:07
Video thumbnail
Selena Alvarez Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:00
Video thumbnail
Denise Johnson Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:11
Video thumbnail
Tammy Smick Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
01:56
Video thumbnail
Maria Ibarra Navarrette Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:07
Video thumbnail
Carol Bradley Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:33
Video thumbnail
Kim Turbin Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:14
Video thumbnail
Tracey Mueller Gibbs Sunset Review 2023 Testimony
02:43
Video thumbnail
Carmen Balber testifies at Sunset Review about Medical Board Reforms
02:03
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges Before
02:16
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt Testifies Calling for Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges before
01:49
Video thumbnail
Maria Ibarra Navarrette Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
00:34
Video thumbnail
Patricia Plascencia Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:04
Video thumbnail
Evelen Martinez Testifies Calling for Death Complaints Must be Investigated before
02:11
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt-Ramos testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges before
02:48
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies on Right to Know Physician Loss of Hospital Privileges Before
01:57
Video thumbnail
Jan Kamel testifies at MBC Meeting 2 9 23
00:34
Video thumbnail
Michele Monserratt-Ramos Testifies in Support of Bringing Medical Board Meetings to Central Valley
02:52
Video thumbnail
Kimberly Turbin Testifies Calling for Serious Bodily Injury Complaints to be Investigated Before
02:11
Video thumbnail
Moises Espinoza Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
01:29
Video thumbnail
Judith Gorcey Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:48
Video thumbnail
Selah O’Connor Testifies Calling for Serious Bodily Complaints Must Be Investigated before
02:39
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:24
Video thumbnail
Tracy Dominguez Testifies Calling for Death Complaints Must Be Investigated Before
02:14
Video thumbnail
Monique Himes Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:15
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley
01:10
Video thumbnail
Xavier De Leon Testifies Calling for All Death Complaints to be Investigated Before
02:25
Video thumbnail
David Gorcey Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
01:14
Video thumbnail
Naomi Sweatt Testifies in Support of Bringing the Medical Board Meeting to the Central Valley 2/9/23
01:05
Video thumbnail
Maria Ibarra Navarrette Testifies Calling for Public Disclosure of Physician Felony Charges Before
02:04

Latest Patient Safety Releases

Patient Safety In The News

Support Consumer Watchdog

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, press releases and special reports.

More Patients Fighting for Change